I don't know how else to say it other than the obvious - Hurley is a great recruiter, developer of talent and team, program builder.
And if his team can outtalent the other team into submission, or if the other team is itself sort of a mess, its a lock - we win the games we are expected to win.
But if its even odds talent wise, and if the other team is tough and disciplined... Hurley's game coaching/management kinda falls apart, and because of that his team falls apart. Its a specific lack of confidence in the moment, in situational awareness. You can see it in some of the panicked and rushed shots. They just aren't built to grind teams out with elite and confidence execution in pressure games/situations. It is what it is. It can improve over time, but not sure how much.
I think this is why we see the team really control games and win the games it "should" if it has an overmatch. They know how to bludgeon and how to crush a team with runs - its really the trademark of this team. But if it becomes an attritional and tactical game focused on exploiting mismatches and making quick adjustments, we are in real trouble. Look at any Villanova game from 2018-2021, xavier/pc/marquette. If we don't knock them out, they grind us until we crack.
Another piece for this years team in particular is expectations - when they started 13-0 and were annointed the king of the Big East, it put a target on their back, and every team will go that much harder, grind a little bit more, dive on the floor to save that possession they wouldn't against like, DePaul. Its new level of intensity that previously we've only seen in NCAA Tourney Games, Villanova games, etc. Games we have really sucked in.