Reply to thread

Message: [QUOTE="nomar, post: 2703319, member: 651"] I'm still not sure any of those 4 guys are better than Webb. Obviously they're all rated higher than he was -- although in the case of Allen, I'm at a loss as to why -- but none of them strikes me as a lock to be a good QB1. Believe me, if Andrew Luck was there at #2, I would have wanted him. I would have been OK with Darnold, as he seemed to be the Giants' favorite, and was my favorite too, but if they'd taken him I'd be nervously reading a lot of articles trying to talk myself into believing he'll be good. Darnold tailed off. Allen's numbers, against weak competition, were horrid. Rosen's maybe one big hit away from retirement, which is troubling since he's the guy most likely to be smacked in the head. And Mayfield's sure got spunk, but there are questions about his maturity, size and reads. Did you like any of those guys a lot? Or Jackson? He was the only guy the Giants could have traded back for and gotten, it seems. [/QUOTE]