Reply to thread

Message: [QUOTE="storrsroars, post: 2843607, member: 2500"] Chad is #1 there IMO. He took some really crappy offenses to playoffs. The guy had a solid arm at Marshall (and Randy Moss) and might've been a truly great one if he didn't mangle his shoulder. Still, he managed to survive a decade in the NFL with a noodle arm mostly by using his head and got to playoffs in the years he wasn't sidelined. I was pretty much done with the Jets when they signed Favre and threw Chad to the curb. I was actually happy when Chad, wearing Dolphin teal and orange, beat Favre and took that last playoff spot. Penny was a great leader of men and, IMO, would be an awesome coach. Vinny was great in the Vinny way, and also didn't have great teams around him. Kenny had great weapons but was too risk averse and concerned about interceptions - he should've won more even with Marino in his division. Boomer... he's still a Bengal to me. [/QUOTE]