OT: Favorite Girl Scout Cookie?

[8893]

I've never seen Rah-Rah Raisin, even though my daughter is in the Brownies.

They are good with milk. Like Do-Si-Dos, Toffee-Tastic and even the incredibly meh-tactic Trefoils. The permeability is the key.

 

[joober jones]

Does Savannah Smiles know Stormy Daniels?

Not sure, but that made me remember the short-lived tv series Savannah. It was on when the WB network was first starting and before it came on, Michigan J Frog would sing, "Send your tadpoles off to bed because Savannah's on toniiiiight!"

 

[B1GEast]

The ones with cocaine in them

 

[8893]

The actual hottest GS Cookie is the smore. They get an extra dollar for them and are flying off shelf.

I’ve got multiple staging areas in the house. Smores are dominating.

View attachment 40852

How did you hold this back until now? I didn’t even know this was a thing.

 

[whaler11]

How did you hold this back until now? I didn’t even know this was a thing.

Smores are $6.

They are the 5G of GS cookies.

 

[8893]

Smores are $6.

They are the 5G of GS cookies.

View attachment 40853

Well this pretty much queers the whole poll now.

Thanks man.

 

[superjohn]

The actual hottest GS Cookie is the smore. They get an extra dollar for them and are flying off shelf.

I’ve got multiple staging areas in the house. Smores are dominating.

View attachment 40852

Don't think I've had a cookie out of a box in the last decade, they are like microwaves to me.

 

[whaler11]

Well this pretty much queers the whole poll now.

Thanks man.

The people that are aware are obsessed. Like zombies who need brains.

 

[whaler11]

Don't think I've had a cookie out of a box in the last decade, they are like microwaves to me.

If I didn’t have a kid I wouldn’t have any cookies. But when you work at home half the time and there are chips ahoy sometimes you grab a few.

 

[I Bleed Blue]

Tagalongs > Everything else. All other opinions are wrong.

 

[John]

True story... I ate a box of samoas and tagalongs on a 10 minute car ride just last week. Not my worst performance. In retrospect, they really are not that good. But there's something crack-ish about them that will always have me eating them.

I ate a box of samoas and tagalongs on a 10 minute car ride just last week

am I reading this right?

 

[uchusky32]

Thin Mints. Taste great frozen.

 

[Kemba429]

Yall sleepin on trefoils

 

[8893]

Yall sleepin on trefoils

The thing that made me start the thread/poll was that my mother in law brought us a box of Samoas and a box of Trefoils the other day and last night I commented that I liked Trefoils least of all the Girl Scout Cookies, although I will still eat them in a pinch. I suspected that they would finish at the bottom here, but you just edged them out of the basement.

I did not see the Thin Mints rally coming. I know they have their fans, but I didn't expect them to be leading the field.

 

[Excalibur]

The actual hottest GS Cookie is the smore. They get an extra dollar for them and are flying off shelf.

I’ve got multiple staging areas in the house. Smores are dominating.

View attachment 40852

That's nothing. My wife is the troop leader. I think we had nearly 300 cases at one point. Our living room looked like a warehouse.

 

[SoFla Steve]

Thin Mints first, no contest.
Then Samoas.

 

[Austin316]

They have knock off Samoas at Adli for $1.99. Taste exactly the same.

 

[dvegas]

They could make Cadbury Mini Eggs from the marrow of baby ducks and I’d look the other way.

take them to a new level with 30 seconds in the microwave at 50% power

 

[jibsey]

The goal is to not eat a whole sleeve at once.

 

[August_West]

If I didn’t have a kid I wouldn’t have any cookies. But when you work at home half the time and there are chips ahoy sometimes you grab a few.

Keebler chips deluxe > Chips ahoy

Sadly I haven’t had either in a long time.


I did binge on some Lemon Oreos recently . Real good and reminded me of my favorite Girl Scout cookie which no one has anymore. The lemon chalet cremes.
Savannah smiles such a lame replacement.

. But man I can’t keep cookies in the house. They are banned for my own sanity.

 

[whaler11]

take them to a new level with 30 seconds in the microwave at 50% power

I hold them in my mouth like skoal until the inside is melted

 

[Kemba429]

The thing that made me start the thread/poll was that my mother in law brought us a box of Samoas and a box of Trefoils the other day and last night I commented that I liked Trefoils least of all the Girl Scout Cookies, although I will still eat them in a pinch. I suspected that they would finish at the bottom here, but you just edged them out of the basement.

I did not see the Thin Mints rally coming. I know they have their fans, but I didn't expect them to be leading the field.

Im fine with being one of the very few that enjoys trefoils the most, as long as Rah Rah Raisins doesnt pass them ill be fine. If that happens, ill raise hell