- Joined
- May 30, 2018
- Messages
- 2,797
- Reaction Score
- 8,106
As a Sox fan I used to respect the guy. Not so much anymore after the “it’s not me episode” with Machado.
Okay, he’s borderline because of his knee injury that will undoubtedly cause him to retire earlier than most. Probably a good chance he still makes it.
Well... I think he was thought of in that context when he won the ROY and MVP...Knee injury obviously should mean nothing because a MUCH better career from Don Mattingly was cut short because of a very bad back. And Mattingly was arguably the best player in the game for 3-4 years and DP never was thought of in that context. I can only say of he gets in before Donnie Baseball it will just tell you how messed up the HOF is.
Well... I think he was thought of in that context when he won the ROY and MVP...
Yeah but Mattingly has those unprofessional sideburnsNo he wasn’t ever. Rookie of the year best player in baseball? Lol and his MVP was purely because the Sox were deserving of one heck he wasn’t even the best on his team nevermind baseball. Maybe the MVP of the team but he got lucky. Morneau was better.mattinlgy was the best player in both leagues in all ways of the game for a while. He’s not in????