OT: Argo

[WhereistheDove?]

I agree. And she really thought she was going to win the Oscar.

In all fairness, she had a couple of award-worthy scenes, but for me it wasn't nearly enough to make up for the complete inconsistency of her performance. When she was good, she was great, and when she was bad, it stuck out like a sore thumb next to Tommy Lee Jones and Daniel Day-Lewis.

 

[nelsonmuntz]

The Master sucked out loud. Self indulgent drivel. And I liked There Will Be Blood.

The Master was horrendous. I feel the same way about There Will Be Blood. Both self-indulgent movies that spend the whole film telling you how important a movie it is. This apparently causes the reviewers to miss the over-direction and over-acting, to say nothing of the gaping holes in the plot. Anderson uses just about every directorial gimmick in the book. Adams and Phoenix spend 2 and a half hours chewing the scenery. It takes 20 minutes of meaningless screen time before Phoenix and Hoffman even meet. It makes absolutely no sense why Hoffman will have anything to do with a drifter like Phoenix. The "Interview" scene in Philadelphia where Hoffman converts Phoenix to the cause is so bad it is comical. This movie is unwatchable dreck.

 

[Waquoit]

The Master was horrendous... This movie is unwatchable dreck.

In it's defense, it did have Amy Adams giving a hand job.

 

[ZooCougar]

In it's defense, it did have Amy Adams giving a hand job.

That was the second creepiest scene in the movie.

 

[nelsonmuntz]

In it's defense, it did have Amy Adams giving a hand job.

To my point about over-direction. Making a character a pervert to show he is a bad guy is one of the weakest story-telling gimmicks in movies. That scene came out of nowhere and had no impact at anything that came afterward. The Phoenix character was a pervert too, which also didn't seem to be relevant to the overall plot. Directors resort to stuff like this when a story doesn't stand on its own.

I almost never say this, but the nudity in The Master was gratuitous.

The more scenes I think about in that movie, the more I think it sucks.

 

[Deadrody]

Guys, rent Silver Linings Playbook. The missus will appreciate it. It's actually not nearly as chick-flicky as you think, there's minimal dancing, and there's lots of Jennifer Lawrence in yoga pants which is altogether fantastic.

I say again: Jennifer Lawrence, yoga pants.

I second the motion. Jennifer Lawrence was smokin' hot in that movie. And the movie was outstanding as well. Definitely better than Argo.

Argo was "good". Not great, not even VERY good. How it wins best picture is beyond me.