I've been trying to reassure myself that swapping Reibe for Giltay is a plus because how limited Reibe was late in the season and we still did well despite his limitations. But a lot of that had to do with how well Reed played down the stretch. We didn't need to lean on Reibe much. Can we expect the same from Hines? Doesn't seem realistic. But if Giltay is in fact a significant upgrade from Reibe then maybe Hines + Giltay = Reed + Reibe. But that's hard math for me to justify without more data on Giltay. We will see.
