I liked Weist and wouldn't have minded if they hired him for the head coaching job. With that said I was also happy they hired Diaco (would have also liked to see Weist remain as OC). What makes you think Weist woukd have done any better? And please don't say the three wins in a row cause they were against 3 terrible teams that ended up with a combined 7 wins on the season, not to mention they were with Cochran at the helm who i believe is a much better QB than Whitmer/Boyle (don't forget about the 41-12 loss to Buffalo, 41-16 loss to Cincinnati, 62-17 loss to UCF, 31-10 loss to Louisville and the 38-22 loss to SMU - we were killed in all the games I just mentioned).
Why are you not optimistic about the recruiting? I believe Diaco was the right hire-he was coming off winning the Broyles award at one of the biggest and most recognizable football programs in the country. While you may think that doesn't mean much, it does carry weight with recruits. So not only did he come from one of the biggest football programs in the country (and win the Broyles award), he also has ties to the NJ area which is huge for UConn recruiting since NJ has a lot of HS talent and since it's almost impossible for UConn to get high level recruits from the HS hothead states (FL, TX, CA , GA, PA, OH - we may get a kid here or there but we will never land a high recruit from those states).
And we have lost this year to 3 teams with a combined 6 wins this year - Army Tulane and USF (they have a total of 9 but take away the 3 wins they have against UConn gives you 6) - with your logic Weist was better.
Weist didnt get to recruit so we cant compare his v.s. Diacos - moot point.
When you say winning the Broyles award is big with recruits - I am not sure that is a fact or something made up. I have yet to see a recruit say I love the coaches, the campus and the fact the HC won the Broyles Award with the nations best LB and a top ten recruiting class.
I dont get the LOVE that goes with this Broyles Award to be honest - past winners
Pat Narduzzi - MIch St - Still an Asst Coach
Bob Diacco - Notre Dame - UConn HC
John Chavis - LSU - Still an Asst Coach
Gus Malzahn - Auburn - HC Auburn (he was on the fast track well before his Broyle Award - he was well known in the region as a genius on offense as a High School coach
Kirby Smart - Alabama - Still an Asst Coach
Kevin Wilson - Okla - HC Indiana - 10-26 in 4 years - this year Rivals has his recruiting class at 77 and UConn at 79
Jim Heacock - Ohio State - Not in coaching - not retained when Urban Meyer took over program
Bud Foster - Va Tech - Still an Asst Coach
Some people are just good assistants - some people are good HC - time will tell but no weight for winning a Broyles in my opinion.