This might be a big time reach, but I wonder if him delaying his decision is because he is very interested in UConn but wants to make sure he has an out in the event that JC hangs 'em up before the summer is out.
Now I don't know the rules as far as taking summer classes. Does anyone know if a player doesn't sign an LOI but takes some summer classes, can he then up and leave to another school in the fall in be eligible right away? To add to this complexity, what if that school foots the bill for those summer classes (I'm assuming the recruit would have to fill out that tuition aid form or whatever it's called). Would be be bound to that program and have to sit out a year if he enrolls somewhere else in the spring?
He seems like a real good fit, in the mold of some of our defensively ready bigs that need time to develop their offensive game. Proximity and style of play would seem to be on our side, and missing the post season for a year would not seem to be a huge issue since he seems like at least 3 year type talent.
IMO, the postseason ban is the spark to the ticking bomb of short JC shelf life. Any recruit considering UConn that equates the NBA success to JC more so than the program likely wrestles with this. I'm sure it's tough for the ones that have other solid options to pull that UConn trigger. My guess a lot of this comes down to how much they like the assistant coach(s) who are recruiting them, particularly KO who some might feel the odds are high that he would continue to stick around when JC calls it quits.
If my memory serves me, JC has 2 years left on his contract. Granted that could get extended, but in most likelihood, the recruits that have committed and the remaining 2012 ones who are still considering UConn are banking on JC being their coach for a couple years and either believe or are wrestling with that being enough to come here.
What concerns me most is the 2013 & 14 classes. Will they feel one year of JC or no years is enough? What impact is the uncertainty that the entire staff could have an overhaul in 2013 or 14? It's simply a tough situation the program has found themselves in. On one hand JC has the right to decide his own fate over the next couple years. Naming Ollie as the Coach-in-waiting might help if the AD really feels that he can do the job. The perceived continuity where JC can choose to leave at any point between now and 2 years might help with some recruits that want to know what the future holds even if there's an A & B outcome. Now if the AD feels he needs to hire a proven coach to move UConn into the future, there simply is no easy way to transition to that. If you make that plan clear, then UConn becomes a huge tough sell. A recruit would have to chose the program for the name on the jersey and not the coach since their future coach would clearly be uncertain. Most players are choosing a program because of the coaching staff of usually the Head Coach in particular.
Sorry to have scurried down this rabbit hole yet again. As Fishy has pointed out, I don't see any upside for JC not making at least next year completely a 100% clear. I'm not really sure even if he did that, it would have much of an impact for the 2013 class which is staring at 1 year max of being coached by JC. This sort of reminds me of when pro coaches are about to enter the final year of their contract. Usually the teams either extend them before that happens or fire them. Again, I do believe that JC has earned the right to leave when he wants and coach the balance of his current contract, but from a "what's best for the program" standpoint, I see 3 options that should have or should be done:
1. Right after the season ended, JC should have announced his retirement and the program should have quickly decided on a new up-and-comer head coach, preferably one that would both attract recruits and do a good job of coaching them up.
2. Announce KO as the Coach-in-waiting
3. And (combined with #2) or tear up JC's contract and extend it out another year so that at least there would be a sliver of perception that a 2013 recruit would have a possibility for 2 years under JC. Once the future looks like at most you'd get 1 year of the current coaching staff, you're really up against a recruiting wall. So far it's been a 2 year-minimum though JC's health has put that in doubt on many occasions and they still seem to find talented recruits who are willing to say "yes".
2.