New Starting 5 | Page 4 | The Boneyard

New Starting 5

Joined
Dec 4, 2020
Messages
1,032
Reaction Score
3,912
I don’t agree that Christyn should be moved out of her starting spot. While she may not be as good as some of our other number 1s, she is not exactly chopped liver! If she were to never shoot more than three threes in a game for the rest of her career I believe we would all be very pleasantly surprised! There is simply no way that she is not solidly among the top five players on this team. Personally, I would rank her as no worse than third and possibly second.
We will have disagree on this one Cuango.

IMHO, thus far this year she has been inconsistent at best on offense, a horrible 3 point shooter and horrible at defense. She has never been a great passer either. As far as being one of the top 5 players, she may be but sure isn't showing it now and it could be we are a better team with a little less CW and more NM or possibly Saylor down the road and others. CW is just not getting it done.

I do hope she rebounds on offense though. I have little confidence in her defence.

I'd like to see how we would do with PB at the two and NM at the one and a bit less CW on the court. See if that helps. I don't think it will hurt.
 
Last edited:

npignatjr

Npignatjr
Joined
Aug 27, 2011
Messages
1,377
Reaction Score
3,401
1. Original starters for all Big East teams (except DePaul). We’ve proven we can win with this lineup for teams that can’t compete. Paige, Liv, Christyn, Evina and Aubrey.

2. For DePaul and SC go small ball. Paige, Christyn, Evina, Nika and Aubrey.
CW EW 3 freshmen starting
 

npignatjr

Npignatjr
Joined
Aug 27, 2011
Messages
1,377
Reaction Score
3,401
I am anxious to see Anna get healthy and return to this team. The offense just works better when she is on the floor. If it turns out that her injury was why her shooting declined and she can start hitting threes at a 40+% clip, I’ll be a happy camper!
Yes without Anna playing 4 on 5 on offense. Right now lost a good passer missing that.
 
Joined
Dec 27, 2018
Messages
30
Reaction Score
204
Yes without Anna playing 4 on 5 on offense. Right now lost a good passer missing that.
I agree. The thorny issue now is not whether one player is better than another, but rather what combination of players puts the best starting TEAM on the court and who are the best players to come off the bench. The TEAM is simply better with Anna starting than without her, albeit a mute point right now. CW and ONO should start, but their games need to be adjusted to their limitations. CW being a more scrappy scorer than shooter, and ONO staying around the basket where she can block shots and make easy layups from great passes by PB and EW. AG is serviceable as a starter, if she can shake off a bad game, but she is still far more valuable off the bench. The freshmen are proving to be terrific, and I trust Geno to use them appropriately as well as teach Aaliyah to do her thing with less fouling. Finally, if EW and, especially, PB, step it up a bit, we'll be fine even though we are very "fine" already.
 
Joined
Nov 3, 2020
Messages
658
Reaction Score
2,591
Should be Nika, Paige, Ev, Cw, Olivia...even when Anna returns. Even though she’s still a bit raw... she is ready and already a natural leader on the floor. When Nika is in the ball moves and she provides defense, relentless effort, scoring, and they will be able to get out in transition more. And If she can consistently knock down her shot, she will be the surprise of this years squad! Also you can move Paige off the ball more when needed to the 2 and the offense will flow more with two great passers also on the floor. Also I like Aubrey off the bench more. So that teams can’t sag in the lane and this will open up the floor. Then along with her bring AE, Anna, and McLean off the bench! Just my opinion after watching the last few games.
Watching Syracuse v Notre Dame. Oh what Huskies could have done with Camilla Cardoso!
 
Joined
Apr 20, 2016
Messages
1,156
Reaction Score
3,403
She is also not a good passer out of the double team. It is what it is.

GA will need to really earn his money this year! He needs to figure out how to put these players in the best situation for them to succeed and that may not be necessarily his preference for the perfect passing/motion offense. Fortunately for him, he has PB and EW! Few teams have players like this and we have 2!

At this point, I think we have enough to challenge for the title this year. It is up to GA to use his players in a way that they can be at their best. We have one dominate player, one very good player and the rest are role players whose success is dependent on that one dominate player.

Coaching needs to make up the rest of our deficiencies to at least get us to the final 4.
Finally, against Depaul, GA ordered the team to reward our big people with a lot of touches. The results were startling!
Our offense ran through Liv and AE against Depaul and we looked like a well-oiled machine. Liv especially with her screens and catches and passing opened it up for the rest of the team.
Running the offense through our two forwards, reminded me of the John Wooden offense with Wicks & Rowe. It was a great change and a big improvement over prior games. And a great boon for CW who played her best game as a Husky.
 
Joined
Dec 4, 2020
Messages
1,032
Reaction Score
3,912
Huh? Nika couldn’t guard my grandmother not a scorer like CW and well never mind. Geno hardly sits her and will never consider your starting 5. Lol Nika over Williams ?
It is not just the scoring that matters and not just a straight swap of NM for CW. I'd want to move PB to the 2G which I think would be a huge improvement over CW and then have NM at the point. Not permanently for the entire 40 minutes, but more often. NM is starting to play more and more and the results, including her defense have been encouraging.

At this point CW is a high volume shooter who shoots very poor from 3 pt land...about 28% for the year (Pre Depaul game). In fact, before the Depaul game she was shooting it at 22% the previous 5 games from when she got benched and only played 14 mins against Providence. She has also missed her mid-range shots, and keep in mind, she has been wide open on these shots. They have not been forced or with a hand in her face.

Overall, CW is shooting at 42% since she got benched through the Ark game. Considering she has been wide-open on the majority of her shots, she has an excellent PG in PB to get her the ball and we played a lot of weak teams during that stretch, she has not been good to say the least. Her defense has been much worst than that.

Although you might think your comment about Nika's defense is funny and clever, it is ignorant of reality. You would be more accurate to say that CW can't guard your grandmother, although I'd say that comment would still be ignorant and adds nothing to the conversation.

I would like to see PB at the 2G in place of CW with NM as the point more often.

This all comes before the Depaul game, which I have not seen yet, but am fully aware that CW went off on offense. I for one, am thrilled she did.
 
Last edited:

MilfordHusky

Voice of Reason
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
37,438
Reaction Score
127,732
Mir and Saylor are the first two players from Maryland in quite a few years.
De'Janae Boykin--who didn't stay very long--was from Maryland. I think Kaili McLaren was from D.C., but her school was in the Maryland suburbs.
 
Joined
Feb 6, 2017
Messages
430
Reaction Score
1,105
It is not just the scoring that matters and not just a straight swap of NM for CW. I'd want to move PB to the 2G which I think would be a huge improvement over CW and then have NM at the point. Not permanently for the entire 40 minutes, but more often. NM is starting to play more and more and the results, including her defense have been encouraging.

At this point CW is a high volume shooter who shoots very poor from 3 pt land...about 28% for the year (Pre Depaul game). In fact, before the Depaul game she was shooting it at 22% the previous 5 games from when she got benched and only played 14 mins against Providence. She has also missed her mid-range shots, and keep in mind, she has been wide open on these shots. They have not been forced or with a hand in her face.

Overall, CW is shooting at 42% since she got benched through the Ark game. Considering she has been wide-open on the majority of her shots, she has an excellent PG in PB to get her the ball and we played a lot of weak teams during that stretch, she has not been good to say the least. Her defense has been much worst than that.

Although you might think your comment about Nika's defense is funny and clever, it is ignorant of reality. You would be more accurate to say that CW can't guard your grandmother, although I'd say that comment would still be ignorant and adds nothing to the conversation.

I would like to see PG at the 2G in place of CW with NM as the point more often.

This all comes before the Depaul game, which I have not seen yet, but am fully aware that CW went off on offense. I for one, am thrilled she did.
Your comment isn’t reality lol sit a # 1 recruit jr out of the starting line up for a freshman who is still learning to play America ball?? If your saying we our playing weak teams and still beating teams by a margin of 33 ppg, what’s the point of changing?? Your right about Nika getting more minutes but she comes in for evina Westbrook who is also a Pg/ playmaker. Williams is a star who just struggles at time with her shooting but still is elite. I mean look at the game Sunday against DePaul. Taking Williams out of the starting 5 will only hurt her confidence. Geno keeps her in to get her out her slump. Why you think she plays the most minutes behind Paige??
 
Joined
Dec 4, 2020
Messages
1,032
Reaction Score
3,912
Your comment isn’t reality lol sit a # 1 recruit jr out of the starting line up for a freshman who is still learning to play America ball?? If your saying we our playing weak teams and still beating teams by a margin of 33 ppg, what’s the point of changing?? Your right about Nika getting more minutes but she comes in for evina Westbrook who is also a Pg/ playmaker. Williams is a star who just struggles at time with her shooting but still is elite. I mean look at the game Sunday against DePaul. Taking Williams out of the starting 5 will only hurt her confidence. Geno keeps her in to get her out her slump. Why you think she plays the most minutes behind Paige??
GA has already sat her once this year (only 14 minutes against Providence) and I have been clear that this is before the DePaul game. CW has been awful at shooting the 3 and playing defense and I could care less what her rating was 3 years ago coming out of HS. Less CW and more NM without affecting the rest of the players could or would be more effective than having CW miss three after three and not being able to guard anybody she is on.

I can see CW had a good game against Depaul, although I haven't finished watching it, but my comments are based on the previous 11 games. She has not been an AA during those games.

Anyway, your most recent comments are certainly more productive than your original ones. Referencing your grandmother in trying to make your points is well......pointless.
 
Last edited:
Joined
Feb 6, 2017
Messages
430
Reaction Score
1,105
GA has already sat her once this year (only 14 minutes against Providence) and I have been clear that this is before the DePaul game. CW has been awful at shooting the 3 and playing defense and I could care less what her rating was 4 years ago coming out of HS. Less CW and more NM without affecting the rest of the players could or would be more effective than having CW miss three after three and not being able to guard anybody she is on.

I can see CW had a good game against Depaul, although I haven't finished watching it, but my comments are based on the previous 11 games. She has not been an AA during those games.

Anyway. you most recent comments are certainly more productive than your original ones. Referencing your grandmother in trying to make your points is well......pointless.
Yes he sat her down. ONO and Westbrook was bench too. Geno done this before in the past if his starters aren’t performing up to his standard. And they all usually get the message like CW did. Speaking of 3s besides Paige and Westbrook the whole team been awful from 3. So instead of Williams missing 3 after 3s means she has to take less and do what she did against DePaul which is drive to the basket and crash the offense of boards not replace her from the starting lineup. And I definitely was being sarcastic when mentioning my Gma but they all get beat off the dribble and slow on rotation even though yesterday game was the best defense game of the season in my eyes.
 
Joined
Dec 4, 2020
Messages
1,032
Reaction Score
3,912
Yes he sat her down. ONO and Westbrook was bench too. Geno done this before in the past if his starters aren’t performing up to his standard. And they all usually get the message like CW did. Speaking of 3s besides Paige and Westbrook the whole team been awful from 3. So instead of Williams missing 3 after 3s means she has to take less and do what she did against DePaul which is drive to the basket and crash the offense of boards not replace her from the starting lineup. And I definitely was being sarcastic when mentioning my Gma but they all get beat off the dribble and slow on rotation even though yesterday game was the best defense game of the season in my eyes.
I know you were being sarcastic. I just don't think it is appropriate nor does it add anything to the conversation. Also, GA sat CW far more than the rest of the players you mentioned. IIRC, she didn't even start the second half.

It doesn't matter as much about the rest of the team's stats with 3s, CW is the starting shooting guard and needs to shoot better than the rest because of that fact alone! Expectations for her are a bit higher than others, so to compare her to other players on the team is inconsequential.

She has been 22% over a the previous 5 games from 3 and missing multiple open mid-range shoots (42% in total) and only 7-12 from the FT line is awful for a starting shooting guard. Not to mention her defense was the worst of any player thus far this year.

It looks like she got going in the DePaul game.

I'm not saying to give up on her. I am a big fan of CW, but she certainly hasn't lived up to the #1 ranking in HS as you pointed out. She is not a consistent dominate player, even against lesser competition. Play her less and maybe we get more from her...
 
Joined
Dec 24, 2020
Messages
144
Reaction Score
290
Huh? Nika couldn’t guard my grandmother not a scorer like CW and well never mind. Geno hardly sits her and will never consider your starting 5. Lol Nika over Williams ?
If CW playing more driving attack the basket then CW>NM
if not , CW playing lazy just wait there for 3s shooting then i prefer NM >CW
 
Joined
Jan 30, 2017
Messages
3,041
Reaction Score
14,438
I'm confused, is CW back in the starting lineup again after the DePaul game?

Confused Dogs GIF
 
Joined
Dec 4, 2020
Messages
1,032
Reaction Score
3,912
If CW playing more driving attack the basket then CW>NM
if not , CW playing lazy just wait there for 3s shooting then i prefer NM >CW
CW gets a lot of wide open looks at the three. She has to take those shots because they are there to take so what I'm thinking is that sometimes (not all the time), we put NM in and we move PB to the 2G. Then maybe they can't give us those threes as much. I think NM's passing abilities would help also.

There is no doubt that CW is the better player than NM and I think you agree, but maybe a little less CW and a little more NM would be good. At least until CW gets out of her slump. Let's say 25 min for CW instead of 38.

Obviously GA doesn't agree at the moment, but that is just how I feel about it.
 
Last edited:
Joined
Feb 6, 2017
Messages
430
Reaction Score
1,105
I know you were being sarcastic. I just don't think it is appropriate nor does it add anything to the conversation. Also, GA sat CW far more than the rest of the players you mentioned. IIRC, she didn't even start the second half.

It doesn't matter as much about the rest of the team's stats with 3s, CW is the starting shooting guard and needs to shoot better than the rest because of that fact alone! Expectations for her are a bit higher than others, so to compare her to other players on the team is inconsequential.

She has been 22% over a the previous 5 games from 3 and missing multiple open mid-range shoots (42% in total) and only 7-12 from the FT line is awful for a starting shooting guard. Not to mention her defense was the worst of any player thus far this year.

It looks like she got going in the DePaul game.

I'm not saying to give up on her. I am a big fan of CW, but she certainly hasn't lived up to the #1 ranking in HS as you pointed out. She is not a consistent dominate player, even against lesser competition. Play her less and maybe we get more from her...
We all know CW struggles but it makes no since taking her out the lineup because we still beating teams by a average of 33% they are still 11-1. If Geno keeps her in the starting lineup then it’s something he knows we don’t. He said that at practice she’s fine just don’t translate into games sometimes. But let’s end this convo. You have your option and I have mines which means mines is accurate since Geno and staff haven’t gone with your logic yet.
 
Joined
Feb 6, 2017
Messages
430
Reaction Score
1,105
If CW playing more driving attack the basket then CW>NM
if not , CW playing lazy just wait there for 3s shooting then i prefer NM >CW
Your right and I said the same thing he should play her less but the thread is about starting lineups not playing more.
 
Joined
Dec 4, 2020
Messages
1,032
Reaction Score
3,912
We all know CW struggles but it makes no since taking her out the lineup because we still beating teams by a average of 33% they are still 11-1. If Geno keeps her in the starting lineup then it’s something he knows we don’t. He said that at practice she’s fine just don’t translate into games sometimes. But let’s end this convo. You have your option and I have mines which means mines is accurate since Geno and staff haven’t gone with your logic yet.
ok
 
Joined
Dec 4, 2020
Messages
1,032
Reaction Score
3,912
So I see you have your wish ? but for the wrong player but she’s still starting. I was wrong lol sort of
I think NM is a good player and with more playing time might be even better. I don't want her to replace CW, just less CW and more NM. I think CW could be better if you reduce her minutes from 35 plus to 25 minutes.
 
Last edited:
Joined
Feb 6, 2017
Messages
430
Reaction Score
1,105
I think NM is a good player and with more playing time might be even better. I don't want her to replace CW, just less CW and more NM. I think CW could be better if you reduce her minutes from 35 plus to 25 minutes.
I like Nika she reminds me of Jen Rizzotti Sue and Bird. I sat and watch the game and I found out how really good she’s going to be. We all talk about pagie but Nika and Edwards has geno trust too. I remember geno said them two just click on early and last night win was freshman’s that carried the team ? scary ? for the future!!!! We coming (Dan Hurley voice)
 

Online statistics

Members online
306
Guests online
1,794
Total visitors
2,100

Forum statistics

Threads
159,604
Messages
4,197,528
Members
10,066
Latest member
Rjja


.
Top Bottom