Reply to thread

Message: [QUOTE="willtalk, post: 3392041, member: 1220"] There are a lot of factors involved in these sort of lists. They are not always a fair evaluation of who the top players really are. The teams a player plays for and preseason and other types of hype do play a major part. nwhoopfans example of Alarie being taken off is one example. It certainly wasn't because of her stats. If given an objective choice ( that would be minus homer eye glasses ) easily more than half the players on the list now would be traded in a heartbeat for Alarie. Another example is that a player's defense does not get equal value mainly because the defense can not really be quantified through stats as the offense can. It is usually considered via reputation only. [/QUOTE]