The beauty of the NCAA tourney is that it gives those lower level teams (provided they took care of what they did have in front of them during their seasons) the opportunity they didn’t have before - to meet these power conference schools on an even playing field, to have the same chance as a Duke or UK or UConn to win a national championship, because they took the hand they were given and handled it well enough to earn that chance.
I miss the days of the A-10, MWC, OG CUSA (or even the early AAC?), even the Valley or occasionally the CAA all being able to get 3-4 teams in the field. Power conference consolidation has obviously killed most of that, with only the MWC hanging on as a usual multibid league. The further we drift from that playing field, the closer we get to the end of March Madness as we know it, and a tournament with just the power conference teams that won’t have the mystique, the intrigue, and most importantly the fairness traditional to this format.
Miami vs. Auburn is really an interesting test for this. Those of you arguing for Auburn, sure, the numbers in a vacuum might favor you. But that misses the nuance of what Miami’s done this season, and their numbers (thanks to literally being undefeated) aren’t too bad, either. If a team can get in with 15 losses just because they went 3-14 in Q1 thanks to their opportunities over a team that literally went undefeated, mathematically unlikely no matter what kind of schedule you play, it’s another sign that our favorite (and the best) sporting event in the country is in its death knell.