Lose a state championship over this? | The Boneyard

Lose a state championship over this?

Status
Not open for further replies.

Blakeon18

Dormie
Joined
Aug 24, 2011
Messages
3,460
Reaction Score
4,488
http://www.highschoolsports.net/spo...eam-a-state-title-in-Massachusetts/51700622/1

I'm a rules-person but I also think good judgment is important. If I am driving safely in a 25mph zone but going 26, I am breaking the law but I hope the police observing my illegal behavior would use good judgment and not give me a ticket.

I don't know if there is a video of this infraction but based on the article the refs should not have denied the touchdown....imo.
 

EricLA

Cronus
Joined
Aug 24, 2011
Messages
14,308
Reaction Score
35,060
first of all, it's a stupid rule. are they kidding with the penalty for celebrating? the penalty for taunting i totally get. getting in the opposing teams faces or making derogatory or vulgar gestures towards the other team should be cause for a penalty. but how many great sports moments have we witnessed from the winning team?

how about Brandi Chastain tearing her shirt off after scoring the winning goal for Team USA in the 1999 world cup? Michael Jordan celebrating after hitting the winning basket vs. Cleveland in 1989 (called THE shot)? those are just 2 iconic moments in sports history. imagine if the goal or basket had been called off due to excessive celebration? personally i think it's a joke (the rule). as i said - taunting? NO. Celebrating? why the hell not?
 

vtcwbuff

Civil War Buff
Joined
Sep 1, 2011
Messages
4,149
Reaction Score
4,751
I saw the video. I'll try to find it again. The kid did nothing but raise his arm in celebration as he was on his way into the end zone. From what I saw it wasn't a taunt.
There is always the possibility that there was something going on in the game before this play
 

Sakibomb25

Yamasaki Let the Good Times Roll
Joined
Aug 29, 2011
Messages
275
Reaction Score
427
I saw the video on ESPN and man, the refs really must be sticklers for the rules. Was he celebrating? Yes. But was it to the point where it would be disrespectful to the other team? No. It was akin to him yelling out loud after the touchdown or hugging his teammates. But oops, that would be considered celebrating and they would be penalized as well probably. To lose a state championship over such a small gesture is really just a travesty to the kids, the school, and its community.

However, rather than complaining about it (the mayor did plenty of that), the coach just said that the kids will take it as a lesson that life isn't always fair, and it's how you respond to adversity that makes you a better person.

I just hope that the refs (and the high school association) get some karma coming their way...
 

meyers7

You Talkin’ To Me?
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
21,878
Reaction Score
27,317
Agree pretty silly call. There was absolutely nothing excessive about it. (I'm not sure why celebrating is bad anyway). MIAA is about the most messed up organization I've ever seen.

Also it was not a "State Championship" per se. They don't have them for football in MA. In most sports they have the champion of Western MA play the champ of Central Mass and then the winner plays the winner of the Eastern Mass (usually divided North and South). But in Football, they just have a Western MA winner, a Cent MA winner and a Eastern MA winner, for each division. (and each section has different divisions). No playoffs for this, just top two teams in each play each other (not sure how they pick them). They call it a Super Bowl. Pretty silly.
 
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
1,538
Reaction Score
847
Why wasn't this sort of penalty assessed on the following play / kickoff?

PS: I saw the video: It was a TERRIBLE call.
 
Joined
Sep 7, 2011
Messages
47
Reaction Score
14
This was he subject of a discussion on "The O'Reilly Factor" last night.Thumbs down all the way on that decision. I say, Let'm play.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Online statistics

Members online
132
Guests online
657
Total visitors
789

Forum statistics

Threads
169,385
Messages
4,173,867
Members
9,065
Latest member
pdxsumeet


Top Bottom