McNeeley is a freshman and he had freshman ups and downs. He showed what he is capable of doing and he has a high upside. If the evaluations come back that he will be a top 20 +/- pick, he should probably go. If he gets feedback on what he needs to improve on to be a lottery pick, then he needs to weigh the pros and cons. No matter what he decides to do, we had some fun watching him, especially the Creighton game.
On a side note, UConn depended on McNeeley to score/rebound way more than Castle last year and it is really hard for a team to rely on a freshman.