Everyone seems to think that recruiting is the only thing that matters. Listen, there is only one coach in the country who isn't a good game coach but is a killer recruiter (and wins): Roy Williams. And he was at Kansas and UNC, where he pulled in the best recruits.
Calipari is a fantastic recruiter and a good (not great) game coach.
Bill Self is a great recruiter and also a good game coach (better than Cal? probably).
Jim Boeheim is a very good recruiter and a good game coach.
Other than Roy Williams--who has a system, and gets the best talent out there--all the other coaches who are fantastic recruiters and sub-par game coaches would be the type of coach we would want to run out of town.
Think: Lavin at UCLA (he may have gotten better in the interim, so we'll see at St. John's)
Think: Barnes at Texas
Think: Drew at Baylor
So I'm looking to see not just how hard they play (very important), but how he's able to manage game situations. We went from someone who was rarely ever outcoached to someone who has never drawn up plays or managed a game. I know KO keeps talking about how he should be judged on how he transforms players into men with character--and explicitly not on Xs and Os. That's an admirable goal. But I don't think that excludes wins. See Jim Calhoun. And Xs and Os are part of it.
I think his team will buy in. I'm not looking for that unless they inexplicably don't (they won't).
I think he can recruit. He's proven that. I think if he doesn't, it's the contract situation.
A good coach turns a toss up (in terms of talent), in a 60% chance of winning, and often wins the games where the more talented team is coached by someone else. Calhoun could beat you with his guys, and then switch teams and win again. That's a high bar; a bar Ollie doesn't have to hit year one. But this is the problem with this hire. UConn is one of the best 10 jobs in the country. There definitely are better, more proven coaches out there. Ollie needs to be able to justify his coaching ability with more than inspirational preacher speak.
I think he can do it. But that's what I'm looking for.