- Joined
- Aug 26, 2011
- Messages
- 91,804
- Reaction Score
- 351,399
It's pretty much the result of the coaching staff never taking him out or trying to develop another running back.
Asinine comment. I guess it has nothing to do with talent and hard work.
I take it you already forgot about Art Thompkins (2019), Nate Hopkins (2017), Arkeel Newsome (2017) and the rushing feats of David Pindell in 2018.
Stupid reply. The post was about the coach not the player. Mensah has had a nice career.
I said nothing about Mensah's talent or hard work. I only mentioned playing time. Why do you think Black left the program? This is a result of Edsall refusing to put in younger player even during blowouts. The same lunacy set back Krajewski who only got a tiny bit of time as a redshirt, when there were plenty of opportunities to get him into four games and have him receive important experience.
Mensah's run at hese numbers would not be possible without Edsall nailing all the back up running backs to the bench, even during blowouts.
It is no secret that much PT is given by Randy from what he sees as effort in practice.Mensah's run at hese numbers would not be possible without Edsall nailing all the back up running backs to the bench, even during blowouts.
I think Mensah is good but I wouldn’t say that hie and Thompkins alternated series. I would guess that it was more like 70/30 percent. However, I thought Thompkins did a good job on punt returns. Even when Thompkins got hurt Edsall kept Mensah in for the majority of the game. That is not how you develop the younger running backs, they need game time experience. Also, it puts a lot of pressure on Mensah. Randy might know how to evaluate talent (which is debatable) but once they get on campus all bets are off.Thompkins was the back-up last year and he was not nailed to the bench, much of the season they alternated series.
As far as redshirt freshman Black goes I wish him luck, that said I think Edsall's best trait as a coach is talent evaluation.
Go ahead and name the players that have left Edsall teams and have gone on to great success somewhere else and made Edsall look bad in the process.
In 2019.
Mensah got 266 carries, 69% of all carries by running backs.
Thompkins --98
Black --13
Monicon --3
O'Reilly --5
Black only saw the field in 6 games and his high carries was 3 in a game. It's impossible to develop with that workload. Given the number of blow outs the Huskies dealt, it would have been easy to get hi carries rather than run Mensah over and over. No wonder Black didn't stick around,
Randy's talent evaluation is debatable? All those 2 stars who made it to the NFL would disagree. As would anyone who is objective in what he does. If you want to knock game management or offensive game calling, you got something to talk about. Saying things that makes you roll your eyes, you got it. But talent evaluation is not one of them.I think Mensah is good but I wouldn’t say that hie and Thompkins alternated series. I would guess that it was more like 70/30 percent. However, I thought Thompkins did a good job on punt returns. Even when Thompkins got hurt Edsall kept Mensah in for the majority of the game. That is not how you develop the younger running backs, they need game time experience. Also, it puts a lot of pressure on Mensah. Randy might know how to evaluate talent (which is debatable) but once they get on campus all bets are off.
Yes, very debatable. You’re saying because two players went to the NFL (out of how many hundreds of recruits)? Look at what he has evaluated since his return. He’s won only six games. It would seem that someone who can effectively evaluate talent would have more wins than that.Randy's talent evaluation is debatable? All those 2 stars who made it to the NFL would disagree. As would anyone who is objective in what he does. If you want to knock game management or offensive game calling, you got something to talk about. Saying things that makes you roll your eyes, you got it. But talent evaluation is not one of them.
Yes, very debatable. You’re saying because two players went to the NFL (out of how many hundreds of recruits)? Look at what he has evaluated since his return. He’s won only six games. It would seem that someone who can effectively evaluate talent would have more wins than that.
Thompkins was the back-up last year and he was not nailed to the bench, much of the season they alternated series.
As far as redshirt freshman Black goes I wish him luck, that said I think Edsall's best trait as a coach is talent evaluation.
Go ahead and name the players that have left Edsall teams and have gone on to great success somewhere else and made Edsall look bad in the process.
Only 2 Edsall players went to the NFL?
That was suppose to be “two star” players. My bad for not proofreading. It’s obvious we disagree about the evaluation part but you are spot on in your other assessments regarding game management and offensive game calling.Only 2 Edsall players went to the NFL?
I don't think he goes down on contact too easily. He fights for yards too.KM is a good back. He has limitations which limit his upside. Can’t get to the edge, doesn’t see holes well, and goes down on contact fairly easily. All that said, he seems to find ways to rack up yardage. So, hats off.
I don't think he goes down on contact too easily. He fights for yards too.
Remember when people commented how jacked he looked at the 2018 spring game? He became harder to bring down after an off season hitting the weights.Agreed. The last two seasons he has broken plenty of tackles and been tough to bring down. He struggled his (true) freshman year and some people can't get that season out of their mind. Mensah didn't get the benefit of a redshirt year like D. Brown, and Andre Dixon did.
That’s why I used “fairly” easily. He’s not a true power back by any stretch. But, he gets the job done.I don't think he goes down on contact too easily. He fights for yards too.
Darius Butler was a 2 star. Will Beatty was a 2 star. Donald Thomas was a 2 star(hell he was a walk on). Marcus Easley. Anthony Sherman and Deon Anderson were 3 stars but at fullback. The list goes on.Yes, very debatable. You’re saying because two players went to the NFL (out of how many hundreds of recruits)? Look at what he has evaluated since his return. He’s won only six games. It would seem that someone who can effectively evaluate talent would have more wins than that.