Karaban is a very valuable role player, but he can’t be the center of the offense because he doesn’t have the ability to create shots for himself or others. Unfortunately, that is the exact skill our current team is in desperate need of. McNeeley and (a healthy) Diarra are really the only guys who can draw the defense and get others open looks, while McNeeley is the only one who can consistently create a shot for himself (though maybe Mahaney could too, if he wasn’t playing point guard). Our team has a bunch of guys who can hit open shots, but being a good spot-up shooter isn’t as useful if nobody can draw the defense to get you open. Our offensive system is incredible and gets us lots of good looks, but without the creators to supplement it, it’s not enough.
Karaban’s lack of ability to create doesn’t mean he isn’t a valuable player. He’s a high-IQ guy who is a good spot-up shooter, excellent passer, good teammate, and has length for rebounding and defense. If Diarra can get healthy and Liam can get back into game shape, this could be a top ten caliber team again. Their ability to create shots will shift everybody back into their natural roles, allowing Karaban and others to go back to the roles they excel at. It is also likely to gradually end Karaban’s shooting slump, which is probably the result of being sped up and forced into a role he isn’t good at (creator).