And my counterpoint to you: I present to you a more accurate comparison than Cayden Boozer, from our own team just 2 years ago: Mr. Ahmad Nowell
County's ranking, according to 247Sport: 36, Composite 48. Nowell's ranking in 2024, according to 247Sport: 33, Composite 37. Practically identical. And furthermore, Nowell was considered more of a pure point guard than County is, who is considered a combo guard.
Diarra knee issue lingers into the season and continues to worsen, Mahaney struggles mightly, Hurley is desperate to turn to the next guy in line, who was Nowell (who also got hurt, but of course that has happened on a yearly basis with 2 to 4 of our guys, so it could happen to County as well). Nowell proved very quickly that he could not handle the position at this level. It helped to torpedo our OOC season, and we ended up with a disappointing season as a result.
You say County has "way more talent than Smith", and stand on that as if it is already proven true... except you have no idea if that is true, or not. I believe in facts and history. The fact is that if we had left our fate at point guard in the OOC season to a freshman again this last year (say, Darius Adams) and not had Malachi we would not have gone 5-1. And it would have materially, negatively affected our entire year, as it did the year before. You can disregard factual history all you want, but since we literally have proof from the last two years, it doesn't make your argument any more plausible.
And here is my mic drop for you: you use Duke's Cayden Boozer as your argument, except that you then have to disavow the fact that his immaturity played a major role in our comeback from 19 points down in the game that ultimately ended their season. He played great in the first half, but not in the second half. And I think most people agree that it was his brain fart to not hold the ball and instead try to pass it forward that gave us the chance to win. Does a junior or senior make the same mistake? I go no further than the mature, head's up play by our senior AK to find the open man in Mullins instead of hoisting up a desperation, contested shot of his own which would have had 0% chance of going in.
Sorry, but the facts line up on my side way more than on yours.