Kind of feared that MoJeff would be short-changed because if you looked blindly at that main stat often connected with PGs (assists per game), you might have given your vote to any three of the other four finalists. But clearly the voters saw her play, considered the overall body of stats, knew what she meant to the top team in the country, and knew that her 43rd ranked apg was at least partly due to less minutes on a loaded team. Review of candidates per stat tests for qualification as the Lieberman winner:
Tiffany Mitchell, South Carolina - Sure she won her coach's award, but Mitchell should simply not have been a finalist, as she is really more a shooting guard who can handle the ball some. Technically a hybrid guard, she led the finalists in points at 14.4 ppg but did not rank among the top 300 players in the country in assists, and her assists\turnover ratio at 1.2 isn't anywhere near the level of the other four players who are PGs. Her reputation as one of the top 5 players in the country is the only reason she was a final 5 finalist for the Lieberman. She did lead the G-c-ocks in assists, but only by 1.
Niya Johnson, Baylor - Her nation-leading apg of 8.9 and 2nd best A\TO of 4.13 obviously made her a top candidate if you rate a PG on just those two main categories, but there are other supplementary stats that were far inferior to the other candidates and that took the luster away from Johnson. She shot only 41.7%, more than 7 points below the next worst rate among the finalists, took no 3-pt shots, and had by far the lowest ppg average. A true PG, but the overall package wasn't as sterling as others, and teams know they didn't have to extend pressure on her on the perimeter.
Samantha Logic, Iowa - She had a great senior year with the 3rd most assists per game nationally at 8.1, had the second best ppg among the 5 candidates, and a pretty good steals rate. She did not shoot as well as Allen or Jefferson even at a fine 48.4%, and the 3pt shooting was at an ehh 32.6%, FT% a surprisingly bad 69.4%, and her A\TO was only fourth best at 2.11 among the finalists, which is good but not elite this year.
Lindsey Allen, Notre Dame - May have been Jefferson's toughest competition based on the UConn - ND prominence. She ranked 30th overall in apg at 5.2, but other than that her stats were all at least a little below Jefferson's except at the line, where she shot 0.7% better. She had a great 53.3% shooting touch, was at 39.2% from the arc, scored 10.5 ppg, a good 2.18 A\TO that was far below Jefferson's, and had the least steals among the candidates.
Moriah Jefferson - Quite simply had the best stats when you get by the 43rd ranking in apg at 4.3. She had the 5th best A\TO nationally at 3.15, the most steals among the finalists at 2.5 spg, in the middle at 12.3 ppg, by far the best shooting at 59.6% overall and 50.4% for 3s, and was a spiffy 84.3% for FTs.
Baby, you're the best.