- Joined
- Aug 26, 2011
- Messages
- 7,397
- Reaction Score
- 18,872
I'm honestly not sure how one can tell with the limited evidence we have. Did GDL make some questionable calls? Yeah, I think so. But I saw a lot of things in the last two years. I saw more dropped passes with wide open WR's than I could fathom. I saw more terrible throws than one would believe. Missed kicks, dropped punts, dropped INT's.
Maybe it's just bad luck. Maybe the cupboard really was bare and Jordan Todman seriously made up for, well, everything else. Maybe GDL isn't that good. My feeling is that it's a combination of all of these things, but most people seem particularly interested in finding a single point of blame (coaching staff) and ignoring all of the other aspects holding us back.
Limited evidence? You're kidding right? Dropped passes with wide open WR's? Davis and Griffin caught everything thrown their way. Unfortunately GDL didn't realize this and when he did Whitmer threw more than one bad passes to Griffin.
While there were drops I did see Phillips improve as the season went on. Nick had his share of drops as did Smith but it was not of epidemic proportions.
The wildcat was idiotic yet he kept trying. He tried to implement a pro blocking scheme that some NFL teams struggle with.
He was not creative by any means. He was unable to adapt at halftime, hence the lack of second half scoring. Throw in a trick play with a QB who just got his bell rung as well a concussion a week earlier, and what you have is a horrible college OC and OL coach.
Really not debatable but please continue.