I will never again complain about the SNY announcers | Page 2 | The Boneyard

I will never again complain about the SNY announcers

Joined
Mar 8, 2016
Messages
3,839
Reaction Score
15,730
And they never mentioned Carol being hurt….even though the camera was on her in the bench several times
In some non-SNY games, it has appeared that the announcing crew did the bare minimum research. Have to wonder if they even knew who Carol was. Frustrating as well when they try to make points based on lack of facts.
 

CL82

NCAA Men’s Basketball National Champions - Again!
Joined
Aug 24, 2011
Messages
59,412
Reaction Score
222,040
Lol, are we really complaining that multiple sports networks want to broadcast our woman’s basketball games? I think the vast majority of us on the board remember when just being able to watch our team on TV, men or women, was a treat.

The broadcast team last night wasn’t perfect, but they weren’t so bad as to be distracting. We could’ve done worse. Monica McNutt comes to mind as an example of that.

For what it’s worth, even our much beloved SNY team isn’t perfect. It amazes me the number of times during the game that Alan Bestwick has no idea what the call is. Someone needs to tell him to watch the refs. And it seems as frequent is not then he’ll call a travel a foul, stopping on the end line a foul, etc. He is just not a basketball guy. Meg is good about gently correcting him. On the other hand, while Meg clearly knows basketball, watching her use the telestrator is so bad that it is actually funny. That said, I am grateful to have them and enjoy their personalities.
 

Bama fan

" As long as you lend a hand"
Joined
Jan 11, 2017
Messages
6,381
Reaction Score
36,769
I find that far too many women's game broadcasts suffer a similar fate. And that is seemingly unrelated to any particular network. We watched Arkansas play Old Miss yesterday after the UConn game. It was on an ESPN channel, and Tiffany Greene and Nikki Fargas were the two announcing. Neither was at the game, and they never stopped yakking about everything but the action on the floor. We would have been far better off to have had the feed from the floor announcer. I would be happy with that at any game, so I know who fouled, or what action caused a turnover, or anything game related. Instead, we get promotions for upcoming games, and stories that often tell nothing related to the current game. Yesterday, watching South Carolina play Bama, they spent time showing us Dawn Staley's shoes, her Eagles shirt, and talking about Pat Summitt while ignoring live floor action. I would say it is free, but nowadays cable and streaming services cost so much that it is far from free. Go Huskies!
 

npignatjr

Npignatjr
Joined
Aug 27, 2011
Messages
1,377
Reaction Score
3,401
Don’t know about that, but surely better than tonight.

For fun, tell Culmo before a game she can’t say the words “heads-up” or “smart play” and she would be silent the entire game. She’s sometimes like a woody doll from Toy Story. She can only say a few key sentences.

There’s a snake in my boot!
Also not allowed to cackle. And no, "pass up a good shot for a great shot or 2 fouls must come out or she can run or she can shoot". How many plays on SNY while the camera is on a coach or player.
 
Joined
Sep 9, 2015
Messages
2,038
Reaction Score
10,953
I don't think I have heard a worse job of announcing since I've been watching WCBB. It was less the play-by-play person than the alleged color commentator, whose windy stories (seemingly told only to prove she'd researched the teams) cut into time when we should have been hearing the play-by-play guy call the game.

It seemed to me that she must have been told to fill all the available air space with words. The resulting verbal diarreah was distracting at best and downright annoying at worst, which was most of the time. Most of what she said was irrelevant to the action on the court at the time. Very little of it had to do with the on-court strategy or other things that would allow the audience to relate to what they were seeing.

The play-by-play announcer was too meek, allowing his sidekick to dominate the air at times when he should have been describing the action.

These folks made Bestwick and Culmo look really, really good.
Is it too much to expect well-paid talking heads to speak grammatically? If I hear "could have went" one more time, I'll (fill in the blank). If we're going to try and communicate, shouldn't we all be speaking/writing the same language? What you say and write defines you and affects your credibility.
I mute all audio on UConn games; hate being told what I'm seeing. I could also do w/out the summarizing of games the instant I finish watching them. Critical thinking means collecting, assimilating, and THEN coming to conclusions. What's the rush to get your thoughts out?
 

psconn

Proud Connecticut WBB Fan
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
3,240
Reaction Score
14,012
I get that it is not a radio broadcast and that we can see most of what is happening but a play by play needs to enhanmce our "vision" by ensuring that we are aware of key facts, stats, strategies and situations. This is especially true in "local" broadcasts where we don't have as many camera angles and slo-mo opportunities. When Lou hit that siiick turnaround jumper from the left baseline neither announcer seemed to notice. That was a remarkable shot in a women's basketball game and was worthy of comment. The announcers were into the ...blah, blah, blah... chat-mode and you wanna scream (and I sometimes do) "are you even watching this game?!? Get your head out of your 'fun chat-notes' and pay attention!!"

I also don't need constant close-ups of coaches and player on the sidelines while the game is in progress. Unless some notable action is taking place there (an interesting interaction or reaction that adds to my understanding or enjoyment), keep the cameras on the game! I am a long-time bench watcher at live games, you can get some real insights BUT the live experience is way different. You can observe both at once.

Anyway, I agree that SNY does a pretty good job overall despite some flaws that were already mentioned.
 
Joined
Apr 14, 2019
Messages
336
Reaction Score
737
I had to mute the sound yesterday because the commentators were making me crazy. I’ll take SNY any day.
 
Joined
Sep 4, 2011
Messages
441
Reaction Score
1,110
For the love of god, please, no more games on CBS. That was horrendous. I can't say I've ever heard two announcers more excited about a possible upset before it happens. They were willing it to happen in the second quarter.
 
Joined
Jun 22, 2012
Messages
2,245
Reaction Score
10,510
Don’t know about that, but surely better than tonight.

For fun, tell Culmo before a game she can’t say the words “heads-up” or “smart play” and she would be silent the entire game. She’s sometimes like a woody doll from Toy Story. She can only say a few key sentences.

There’s a snake in my boot!
You mean like Doris Burke used comportment and how every single announcer (men and women) overuse the word physicality?
 
Joined
Jul 20, 2021
Messages
758
Reaction Score
5,088
For the love of god, please, no more games on CBS. That was horrendous. I can't say I've ever heard two announcers more excited about a possible upset before it happens. They were willing it to happen in the second quarter.
Unfortunately they are doing Senior Night.
WHY!!??
 
Joined
Sep 12, 2011
Messages
225
Reaction Score
848
I grew up obsessed with play-by-play of sports, with Marv Albert for basketball and hockey (Dan Kelly on TV), Marty Glickman for football, and Rizzuto, Coleman, Red Barber and Mel Allen for baseball. I was the co-play-by-play voice of our basketball team on the college FM radio station, training incoming freshman and sophomores.

FOR ME (horses for courses), women's basketball broadcasts are sub-par, SNY particularly so. Unlike the men's games, where the the analyts are tactical, the women's side amplify what we are seeing. "That was a great cut." "What a block!"

Much prefer the late Billy Packer's dissection of offense and defense tactics. Al McGuire's (my personal favorite) idiosyncratic analysis laced with humor and deprecation. "Get it to the senior" in the last minutes, "Stop the ball" - things I took into my own coaching dalliances. They'd question coaching decisions, discuss upcoming critical choices. Jim Nance (who I don't fancy as a football announcer) conveyed a seriousness about each play. Things like playing "2 for 1" against the shot clock at the end of a quarter.

The women's game has all the same nuance and strategy as the men's. For me, it's disappointing the network talent doesn't treat it as such.
 
Joined
May 16, 2017
Messages
6
Reaction Score
55
I don't think I have heard a worse job of announcing since I've been watching WCBB. It was less the play-by-play person than the alleged color commentator, whose windy stories (seemingly told only to prove she'd researched the teams) cut into time when we should have been hearing the play-by-play guy call the game.

It seemed to me that she must have been told to fill all the available air space with words. The resulting verbal diarreah was distracting at best and downright annoying at worst, which was most of the time. Most of what she said was irrelevant to the action on the court at the time. Very little of it had to do with the on-court strategy or other things that would allow the audience to relate to what they were seeing.

The play-by-play announcer was too meek, allowing his sidekick to dominate the air at times when he should have been describing the action.

These folks made Bestwick and Culmo look really, really good.
Who did the game on CBSSN?.....Only game of the year that I missed on TV, because my provider doesn't have CBSSN....Just an old guy in Texas (sitting right between Baylor and UT) who has followed the Huskies since '95...I love your coverage and the comments on here from REAL WBB fans....!!...Also appreciate the Boneyard 'rules'....Keep up the good work.....Texron
 

Biff

Mega Monster Moderator
Joined
Aug 15, 2011
Messages
3,300
Reaction Score
24,898
I grew up obsessed with play-by-play of sports, with Marv Albert for basketball and hockey (Dan Kelly on TV), Marty Glickman for football, and Rizzuto, Coleman, Red Barber and Mel Allen for baseball. I was the co-play-by-play voice of our basketball team on the college FM radio station, training incoming freshman and sophomores.
Marty used to do the UConn men's basketball play by play on the radio (70s/80s?) That's pretty much all you could get for coverage back then in the field house days. I used to love his call. As an aside I had no idea of his sports history back then. Quite a story.
 
Joined
Dec 31, 2019
Messages
23
Reaction Score
110
I appreciate broadcasts which don’t insist on telling us what we just saw or inform us minute by minute about how many points so-and-so has. Worst is the time-wasting absurdity of supposedly meaningful stats wherein, for example, player X is shooting 48% from three this year but “only” 2-6 in the game right now.

And as to cliches — someone should write a book. They probably have.
 
Joined
Sep 12, 2011
Messages
225
Reaction Score
848
Marty used to do the UConn men's basketball play by play on the radio (70s/80s?) That's pretty much all you could get for coverage back then in the field house days. I used to love his call. As an aside I had no idea of his sports history back then. Quite a story.

Absolutely! Without elaborating so as not to sidetrack the topic - folks should G00gl3 him. Quite a story indeed!

His football broadcasts with Al DeRogatis were sensational and revelatory.
 
Joined
Dec 12, 2020
Messages
44
Reaction Score
692
To me, a lot of the complaints are first world problem level of complaints that is pretty representative of how spoiled the fanbase is.

I guarantee that fans of Stanford, South Carolina, and other great teams would KILL to have the game availability and dedicated local coverage that UCONN has, games that won't be preempted by a men's game like what the Big Ten teams have to deal with. Bestwick and Culmo aren't perfect but they are good.
 

Bama fan

" As long as you lend a hand"
Joined
Jan 11, 2017
Messages
6,381
Reaction Score
36,769
Anyone who listened to Carolyn Peck call the game between LSU and Tennessee last night should appreciate the SNY team. She usually has a player she picks to highlight and points them out during her broadcasts. And last night's player du jour was Ms Angel Reese from LSU. Peck referred to her as "Bayou Barbie" in a most repetitive and annoying manner. I find Ms Peck very hard to take. Give me the SNY team anyday!
 

MSGRET

MSG, US Army Retired
Joined
Dec 16, 2017
Messages
6,678
Reaction Score
37,692
For the love of god, please, no more games on CBS. That was horrendous. I can't say I've ever heard two announcers more excited about a possible upset before it happens. They were willing it to happen in the second quarter.
The last televised SNY game is on 2/21 against St. John's at the XL Center. They have five games left, @Providence, Marquette 2/8, @Georgetown 2/11, Creighton 2/15 at Gampel, and the St. John's game. Fox has 3 games South Carolina 2/5 at the XL, @Nova 2/18, and @DePaul 2/25. CBS Sports has the Senior Night game at Gampel on 2/27. By the way the pecking order of who gets to choose the games that they want to televise is FOX, CBS Sports, then SNY when it comes to home games and non ESPN televised road games.
 
Joined
Oct 15, 2011
Messages
2,100
Reaction Score
5,188
I do not know if I am the only one to notice this, but lately, Meghan laughs at things that are not remotely funny and her laugh is like nails down the chalkboard. Just saying. Har har har.... Oh my.
 
Joined
Dec 2, 2018
Messages
740
Reaction Score
4,417
I seem to be able to mostly tune out Carolyn Peck. There are really only a few excellent analysts (Rebecca Lobo, Kara Lawson before she switched to coaching, Doris Burke before she was promoted to the NBA); I just let the others roll off my back. It should be noted that Peck was the only one of the three pregame commentators who correctly picked Connecticut to beat Tennessee (choosing with her brain instead of her gut?). One analyst I miss from watching hockey in the glory days (late 1980's) is Bill Clement.
 

psconn

Proud Connecticut WBB Fan
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
3,240
Reaction Score
14,012
Nika's been bodying up opposing players all over the floor. Great D as long as the wwhistles don't blow. She HAS gotten away with a couple and I'm good with it.
 

Online statistics

Members online
111
Guests online
1,674
Total visitors
1,785

Forum statistics

Threads
159,777
Messages
4,204,671
Members
10,075
Latest member
Imthatguy88


.
Top Bottom