How is he doing her disservice? You mean it's only about "minutes?" And that's what Geno promised her? In addition you don't think she knew coming in that she was going against other h/s all-americans that she probably wouldn't break into the rotation in her 1st two years? And how often have we heard that a kid according to the coach when they first coach her is "more athletic than we thought?" Or "is more skilled than we thought?" Geno has to see them in practice. If some are "worse than you thought" when you recruited them then there are also some that are "better than you thought" too. And has Geno done a disservice to Molly Bent too?
And are we arguing the same thing? You asked why Irwin isn't playing more. I'm not arguing what she is "going to be." I'm arguing what she is right now. You spoke of playing right now. As for athleticism, Kaila McLaren wasn't athletic but she got minutes. Heck there was a stretch of time Geno had her ahead of Tina Charles. And in Doty's senior year she got minutes even though her athleticism was gone. I don't think we are arguing the same thing. I specifically addressed your question as to why she isn't playing at this moment. Just as DOty and McLaren weren't athletic - they got more minutes - so can kyla in big games down the road.
I was wondering if you could answer a couple of questions for me? You just said that Kyla is going to be good. She only got 7.8 minutes last year. Yet what you're saying is that she is going to be good (I am not arguing with you on this as to what she will become). So she has improved enough to make you believe the non h/s all-american is going to be good even though she played just under 8 minutes. So a freshman can improve playing under 8 minutes and still turn out to be good, right? And reading from your posts you don't seem ot think the freshmen are that good otherwise you wouldn't be so concerned about the future as much as you have said previously. So-- are you saying you believe Kyla will be a better player than all of the freshmen? Two of the freshmen? One of the freshmen? If you think Kyla is going to be good, in order to be concerned about the future, are you saying you saw from the start of Kyla's career and even maintain right now that Kyla is going to be better than the freshmen in the future? I don;t understand prior points of your concern for the future especially since only 7.8 minutes lats year you already see that Kyla is going to be good.
Let me try to answer your questions:
First of all when Kyla was a freshman I saw a girl with potential. I saw flashes of a tough kid, that didn't look completely overwhelmed, as well as a kid that had the confidence to take and make a shot. Coming into her Soph year I saw how much work Kyla put into getting into better shape. In limited minutes I've seen a girl that has showed more leadership and confidence. Again I am not the coach and don't see practices but in my heart I believe that if Kyla were given minutes she would flourish. Now another poster countered me and said there is a log jam at 4-5 and he was right.. Out of the sophomore class clearly I was one of the few that stressed that Danger is/will make the jump and if she does she will start. I think 2 of the 3 sophomores are solid players. I personally don't think Molly will evolve into a great or even a trusted role player. Again its just my opinion and I can be wrong.
Will Kyla be better than the Freshman? Im hoping Megan Walker turns out to be special, like a cut about a solid player... I would think Megan has more potential with the skills she possesses.. I thought AEH was going to be special, a lot better than others think on this board. I expect really good things from her and actually think her transfer was a good sized loss for the program.. Its hard to compare a 2 and a 4 but I think Kyla has more talent than Lexie and maybe coombs... Not sure I really haven't seen enough Coombs to have a true GUT feel...
I think as a soph Kyla has paid more dues and been in camp Geno longer than the Freshman and that is helpful.
I think that the 6 starters should not play the entire game(minus last 4 minutes of a blow out). I think the bench should be worked in after the first few minutes of each half. How dare Geno have KLS in the game in the 4th quarter up by 25-35 points with 4 minutes to play like he did last week( 2 games ago)?? Especially with her ankles and propensity to get shoved and hacked. She went up for a layup at the 4 1/2 minute mark in the fourth and got destroyed.. Really I need to see that??
Its ok to disagree with me this is all just my opinion.