We need two point guards and if you thought Gaffney were going to be injured all year, you'd want Cole to be eligible. But we don't think that.
Gilbert is going to play whether Cole is eligible or not -- it's his last year and his time to show. So Cole's minutes, if he became eligible, would be taken from Gaffney. I think the priority here is to develop Gaffney. Cole has D1 experience, knows what he needs to work on, and has the maturity to work on it while he's not playing. Gaffney needs playing time to learn what he needs to work on next summer. The team will be best next year if Gaffney, rather than Cole, gets available backup PG minutes this year.