We have a historical reference point at this very university to rely on for judging the performance of this team. When Calhoun took over, UConn was the 8th / 9th best team / program in the Big East. He did not build the program into national prominence by getting 5 star recruits. Even at the height of the program's success, he was still not bringing in any more than 1 top 30 player in any given year, and usually, not even that.
The really ironic thing is, one of these posts references Ben Gordon. Fact is, Gordon was an under the radar recruit, I don't recall the reasons, but he was not a top 30 guy, nor was Okafor. That 2004 championship team was probably the most talented team Calhoun ever coached. The only McD's all americans on the team were Taliek Brown - oh the irony - and Charlie V (who didn't contribute much, especially in the tournament). Calhoun was competing for national championships against programs with rosters full of McD's AAs. I mean, seriously, tell me about how UConn was one tipped pass away from going to the Final Four in 1990 and all the 5 star recruits that made it possible. I'm not saying Kevin Ollie has to be as good as a HOF coach. The point is, coaching is about making the team more than the sum of it's parts, and using strategy to overcome the various weaknesses of individual players and the team overall. Full court pressure defense leading to transition offense was a hallmark of early UConn teams because they often did not have the upper echelon talent that the Duke, Kansas, UNC programs had.
The bottom line here is that the reference point is, you can compete nationally, AT UCONN, even when considered a conference doormat, by coaching the players you can get, which were not 5 star recruits when Calhoun started. That's just a fact.
Bitching about not having enough 5 star recruits is nonsense. I'll grant you that the fact that Ollie also can't seem to recruit players to come to UConn also does not work in his favor, but you do not have to have 5 star recruits to compete nationally, let alone in the AAC. These facts do not paint Kevin Ollie in a very flattering light.