It's a result-based business. Count the banners. Count the bowls.
You'll run out of fingers.
Under Hathaway, the department achieved results in some fairly serious headwinds - some completely external like the disintegration of the Big East Conference. If you want to assign all of the blame for whatever to the man and none of the credit, go for it. He wasn't perfect and it was time for him to go, but at least judge him on the merits, not some vague impossible-to-quantify zls44-style 'he didn't lead...ever...at all...never...ever' rant.
I think the complaints are very specific and accurate. That's likely why you are sidestepping them.
But again, I have to agree with you there is no doubt that Hathaway got results, fundraising down, one public relations disaster after another, major sanctions,...the guy was a gem. But in the end, we won and that was directly the result of Jeff Hathaway, not the two hall of fame coaches, not FUCRE, but Jeff. Did he even hire any of them?
If you want to give him credit for something he actually achieved, give him credit for negotiating that rolling six year contract that kept his incompetent ass in place for far too long.