bballnut90
LV Adherent. Topic Crafter
- Joined
- Dec 19, 2011
- Messages
- 7,471
- Reaction Score
- 33,588
The foul trouble point doesn't make sense. Reese was foul prone while at Maryland in addition to this past season at LSU. Both players can get their defensive opponents in foul trouble as well. Personally it's a wash.
It's also hard to compare these two because they play different styles of basketball based on how their team's offence are set up. LSU ran a lot of their offence through Angel, which wasn't the case for Aaliyah at UConn. Reese wasn't expected to defend the perimeter as much as Aaliyah was. Plus Reese's outside game is still lacking. Let's see how it develops next season and do a comparison then.
Reese shot 9.4 free throws per game compared to 4.1 for Edwards--she's drawling a lot more fouls than Aaliyah does.
In regards to getting into foul trouble, Reese has her moments but it's rare she misses significant playing time or stays off the court long. Edwards has improved in this area looking at season stats--I just recalled her missing significant minutes in several big games (Ohio State/South Carolina). Committing fouls I agree is largely a wash when looking at the numbers on the season.
The players have different skill sets, but while Edwards showed flashes of greatness throughout the year, Reese maintained that level of play and tenacity the entire season which is why I think she's clear cut ahead of Edwards, though Edwards had a great season in her own right. If Edwards can find more consistency then it's a new conversation IMO.