Our "monster" classes never ranked higher than 6 out of 8 Big East teams, and off the top of my head I'm pretty sure we were 7 or 8 out of 8 every year in the Big East except maybe one 6th. P actually did a decent job of bringing in "bigger" name kids than Edsall. We have 2 guys in the Big33 game coming in this year from P and he brought in Vann and Ashiru after only being here a month or so. Obviously P didn't do a great job on the field, but we can't rewrite history and pretend like he wasn't an upgrade in "scout/rivals" recruiting over Edsall. Edsall did more with 2 stars than anybody, but Whitmer, Boyle, and Cochran were all players that we didn't think we'd get with Edsall at the time and we were very happy to get them.
So far, Diaco has been able to hold on to some good prospects and was able to bring in 4 guys his first open weekend so we should be pleased. P has left him with some talented players. Realistically the only positions that we're lacking in right now are the OLine and running back, and I think the only reason we are down there was due to GDL being terribly bad at his job. Foley will has those units running fine in time put a win together against the Stormin' Mormons next season. Hopefully Diaco and company pull in a big get or two before signing day but I'm certainly not going to judge his recruiting on this first class. I'm pretty sure he and a few other guys on the staff were recruiting coordinators so theoretically we have reason for optimism.