Nobody goes there anymore... it's too crowded...
People go there, but it's really over-rated. They opened a pizzeria on Valencia and 18th, and it is also over-run.
But as other locals will point out, you are in the Mission district, why are you going to any place other than El Faro?
For Italian food, Barbacco is easier to get reservations for and is, IMO, much better. Perbacco is next door and they are pretty good, as is the Tadich Grill, the oldest restaurant in EssEff.
Out of the tourist areas (and in my neighborhood) is La Cicca a Sardinian restaurant that is interesting, Eric's which is some really good Chinese, and Uma Casa, a Portuguese restaurant.
Oh and Bob's Donuts SUCKS! Happy Donuts or no donuts at all. (F%^&*() Hipsters and their bacon maple donuts)