OT: - DraftExpress's Jonathan Givony on Alex Karaban | The Boneyard
.-.

OT: DraftExpress's Jonathan Givony on Alex Karaban

Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
12,155
Reaction Score
46,209
DraftExpress is no longer under the ESPN banner and is back to working independently, the AK comments are at the 1 hour, 32 minute mark if the video doesn't automatically start there. He's much higher on AK than other mocks right now, says he has him in his top 20.

There's also Castle/Spurs talk at the very beginning of the pod.

 
DraftExpress is no longer under the ESPN banner and is back to working independently, the AK comments are at the 1 hour, 32 minute mark if the video doesn't automatically start there. He's much higher on AK than other mocks right now, says he has him in his top 20.

There's also Castle/Spurs talk at the very beginning of the pod.


20 in this draft would be something. Eye of the beholder.
 
AK is a very good defensive player guarding the 4 at the college level. Can he be above average guarding the 4 at the NBA level? And can he shoot close to 40%+ from three?

If he can do those two things he will have a nice NBA career. Because his smarts and winning plays will certainly carry over.
 
Maybe I’m being a debbie downer but I don’t think Karaban’s NBA profile has really changed at all since his sophomore year. Stretch 4 that is a great passer and very smart player who always knows where to be. Limited athletically and defensively (although his defense has improved every year)

So if he was a fringe first round pick after sophomore year and probably somewhere between 30-40 after junior year, not sure why he’d jump into the top 20 now unless he pops off in March and plays himself up a few spots like Hawkins and Andre did
 
.-.
Maybe I’m being a debbie downer but I don’t think Karaban’s NBA profile has really changed at all since his sophomore year. Stretch 4 that is a great passer and very smart player who always knows where to be. Limited athletically and defensively (although his defense has improved every year)

So if he was a fringe first round pick after sophomore year and probably somewhere between 30-40 after junior year, not sure why he’d jump into the top 20 now unless he pops off in March and plays himself up a few spots like Hawkins and Andre did
In the most loaded draft of those 3 years too. Makes little sense.
 
Any improvement since his sophomore year will be negated by being two years older from a draft order perspective.
 
Is there value in having a guy like him on the roster who day 1 will be able to come in and learn the playbook offensively and defensively and who can knock down a 3 and make the right passes - even if there's a hard ceiling? I think he's too unathletic to get meaningful minutes but I don't follow the NBA enough to say.
 
Karaban seems like he could be a Sam Hauser+ in the league. And he's got a high floor. With how many busts there are in the draft - like James Nnaji for instance - I could see a team taking a first round swing on him.

And speaking of Nnaji, Givony seems to not have any grasp of the bigger picture of the pro-to-college pipeline that's developing. Kind of a "let's all walk off a cliff because the rules say so" type, in my opinion.
 
Conference POY updated predictions from Myron Medcalf of ESPN.

Big East Conference

Preseason prediction: Zuby Ejiofor, St. John's

Updated prediction: Alex Karaban, UConn

The epitome of consistency, the senior star has connected on 59% of his shots inside the arc and 44% of his 3-point attempts, ranking 21st nationally in Evan Miya's efficiency ratings. The 6-foot-8 forward is the anchor of a UConn team that could tear through a conference schedule that's weaker than last season's Big East.

Top competition: Solo Ball, UConn (15.4 PPG, 3.5 RPG)


 
.-.
I just don't see it. I wouldn't take him in the first round as an NBA GM. I think he can probably carve out a career but I really don't think he'll ever play major minutes. I hope he proves me wrong and exceeds all expectations like Cam has.
 
I just don't see it. I wouldn't take him in the first round as an NBA GM. I think he can probably carve out a career but I really don't think he'll ever play major minutes. I hope he proves me wrong and exceeds all expectations like Cam has.
Well he has a high floor. Which might be a worth a bottom third first round pick. Go back and look at the first round of the last few drafts. Lots of duds. Picking outside the top half of the first round is a crapshoot pretty similar to the 2nd round draft choices.
 
I love AK. But I think he’s lacking the athleticism to stick in the NBA. He may kick around as an off the bench shooter but he’s way too small to guard nba 4’s. He has to come off the bench as a 2-3 instant offense shooter. He’ll make his money overseas and then I see a very very successful coaching career for him.
 
I can see AK with a KO career in the NBA. He's not flashing, but is a reliable high basketball IQ guy. The kind of guy that you could bring in on 10 day contracts to help as needed. You never know, though, he may catch on somewhere since he's a high character, team first guy. If he doesn't connect in the NBA, though, he will certainly have a pro career in Europe.

Obviously, I'm rooting for him to finish his senior year with a national championship, which would be an awesome way for him to go out. Being a three-time national champion certainly isn't going to hurt his draft profile. I don't know if being our only three time national champion puts him on Connecticut's "Mount Rushmore" because we've had so much talent come through here, but winner lose, he'll still be a favorite husky for me. Just an outstanding kid. I'm glad he's been a part of our program for the past 25 years.
 
I love AK. But I think he’s lacking the athleticism to stick in the NBA. He may kick around as an off the bench shooter but he’s way too small to guard nba 4’s. He has to come off the bench as a 2-3 instant offense shooter. He’ll make his money overseas and then I see a very very successful coaching career for him.
AK is 6'8 in shoes with a 6'11 wingspan, and after the weight in muscle he's put on he's gotta be around 225-230 now, he's not guarding 2s in the league unless it's a switch and if he does stick it will be as a 3-4.
 
DraftExpress is no longer under the ESPN banner and is back to working independently, the AK comments are at the 1 hour, 32 minute mark if the video doesn't automatically start there. He's much higher on AK than other mocks right now, says he has him in his top 20.

There's also Castle/Spurs talk at the very beginning of the pod.


At least Givony says his wingspan is 6'11" - not 7'9" like our buddy Dauster.
 
.-.
Well he has a high floor. Which might be a worth a bottom third first round pick. Go back and look at the first round of the last few drafts. Lots of duds. Picking outside the top half of the first round is a crapshoot pretty similar to the 2nd round draft choices.
Yes, the NBA draft has changed a bit. It's always about landing a star in the lottery, at least a future starter. You project and draft for upside. Occasionally those guys also have a high floor, like Flagg. Then teams start making decisions about (a) guys who still have upside and are raw or (b) older guys who have a decent shot of becoming reliable bench players. Using the Celtics as an example Walsh was type (a). The next year they took Baylor S. who was type (b). AK is clearly type (b). Go back 10-12 years and the type (b) guys were almost all second rounders. Lately more have gone late 1st. I think the salary cap and tax penalty is causing teams to prioritize cheap rookie contract depth on the bench. NIL is also causing more of those guys to stay in school giving teams a longer look at them.
 
I just don't see it. I wouldn't take him in the first round as an NBA GM. I think he can probably carve out a career but I really don't think he'll ever play major minutes. I hope he proves me wrong and exceeds all expectations like Cam has.
And even with Cam he has to be a 50/40/90 guy to do this.

Karaban hasn’t shown to be a very efficient player during his time here which would be absolutely needed if he wants a chance at the next level.
 
Just takes one team to believe in his defensive ability/athleticism. I have little doubt he can contribute offensively. He does so many great off-ball things and can be a really good supporting piece. I’m not sure I see the athleticism being good enough on defense but I’m no expert and certainly hope I’m wrong.
 
And even with Cam he has to be a 50/40/90 guy to do this.

Karaban hasn’t shown to be a very efficient player during his time here which would be absolutely needed if he wants a chance at the next level.
My main concern with Alex comes from what @aceboon mentioned above. He's not quick enough to defend 1s or 2s. Many NBA 3s would blow by him but there are enough less athletic shooters in the league that he can get by. Then there's 4s, where he gives up a lot of size and athleticism to many of them. You like him on LeBron? Giannis? Banchero? Mobley?

I don't see any position where he'd be an average or better NBA defender. So his offense would need to be really special. I truly hope he has a long, successful career, but I wouldn't be surprised if most of it is in Europe, where I think his game fits better.
 
And even with Cam he has to be a 50/40/90 guy to do this.

Karaban hasn’t shown to be a very efficient player during his time here which would be absolutely needed if he wants a chance at the next level.
Outside of last year his efficiency has been fine imo, this year easily his best so far but AK was pretty efficient last year as well starting out in BE play before he nosedived. The easy NBA comp for AK is Georges Niang, Niang was a better college player and had the ball in his hands more, but in the NBA he scaled down to a corner boy and a connector. Same type of role AK will play if he sticks, Niang also posted similar pre-draft measurements as AK did when he went through the combine in 2024.
 
Tough draft class for AK. Had he one more year…:

Maybe he goes to Europe, maybe the G, maybe he finds the right NBA team who needs a 4 at low price vs a vet that retires. I could see the Sixers if George is unplayable but let’s let the rest of the season play out.
 
.-.
And even with Cam he has to be a 50/40/90 guy to do this.

Karaban hasn’t shown to be a very efficient player during his time here which would be absolutely needed if he wants a chance at the next level.
Don’t understand saying he hasn’t been efficient here. Came within a whisker of being a 50/40/90 guy as a sophomore, and only feel from that level last year after being concussed. And now he’s around those levels again healthy.
 

Online statistics

Members online
43
Guests online
10,459
Total visitors
10,502

Forum statistics

Threads
166,319
Messages
4,475,909
Members
10,350
Latest member
Donec


Top Bottom