On the comments about JC and other drill sergeant type coaches, while JC did lose a player here or there every so often, it is pretty safe to say that JC always had the kid's best interests at heart and the few who did not initially realize this were the players who departed.
As far as the love that players feel for Brown vs DeLeone, it id very safe to state that football players (who approach this level) by nature are aggressive and would normally prefer an attacking style of play allowing them to be physical and use their athleticism.
One (of many) areas where what GDL is doing would not garner praise is that he has changed the line's philosophy from an aggressive, physical style to a passive, reactive one. Instead of being able to deliver the blow, the linemen now are asked to receive it.
From what I understand where GDL has failed is that he is either unwilling or unable to fully communicate what he wants from the linemen and what their responsibilities are and becomes very condescending and demeaning when they appear to be poorly instructed. This and his (I'm guessing insecurity driven) dismissive manor towards other offensive assistants has me wondering if he fully understands the blocking schemes he wants to run.
I have seen this from you several times. I would love to know the source of this information, this is some serious stuff you are putting out.
As I've responded before, I'll say again. I could care less about a coach's personality traits and how he treats his players. It's the results that matter. If the results we are getting on the field, is becuase the players aren't mentally, emotionally able to handle a bastard old coach that screams and spits all the time, and berates you non-stop?
Well, you know what? I'm not going to put that on the coach. If the system works, and it's functional, and the players aren't accepting it or learning it because they don't like the way the coach treats them? Well, I've got some words for the players in that case, and they're the potty mouth kind.
This is why I'm SO interested in knowing who, why and how things keep getting screwed up on offense. MIssed assignments, confused looking players. Missed blocks.
#1. If the plays are getting destroyed, because the players are doing exactly what they've been coached to do, and as I've seen so many times, we can't get a defensive front blocked with more blockers than defenders?
Then the coach's system is a failure.
#2. If the plays are falling apart, becuase the players know what they're supposed to do, but simply don't physically do it?
Then we need better players.
#3. If the plays are falling apart, because the players - at this point in time - still can't get the assignments right?
Then, there is a failure in the coach's ability to teach his system, and the coach either needs to change the system to somethign the players can get right, or needs to put players in that do know the system.
My gut tells me that the problem on offense is somewhere between #2 and #3, and I can tell you, that if the problem regarding #3, is because our players feelings are hurt, by bastard old coach, getting in their face and screaming and spitting and calling them pansies and dumb and what not?
Then we most definitely need new players.
See-
becasue if you're going to go that route, with evaluation - how do you differentiate between a coach that is going to be every player's good friend, but isn't getting results, vs. a cocah that' is a complete, absolute , and nobody's friend, but isn't getting results?
It's results that matter. If the results we're getting, are because the player's don't like their coach's personality style, and don't accept the system because of that?
I've got a problem with the players for that, not the coach.
My opinion, can all change very quickly, if I were to know that the offensive system that Deleone is teaching, is simply so fundamentally flawed, that we can't get a 6 man pass rush blocked by 7 people.