My disenfranchise comment went to answer Whaler when he suggested a Depth chart of Whitmer, Foxx, Boyle and Boyle starting the next game if need be.
Once Cochran retired, the chances of Boyle redshirting decreased a single digits. Redshirts aren’t awarded until after the season. So if Whitmer is health all year, crisis averted. OTOH, how do you handle that internally with real people? Anyone who knows anything about football knows that every team needs a backup QB, particularly the backup QB.
You can disenfranchise Boyle more by preaching Next Man Up, demonstrating that Boyle is just that in practice, and then playing a non-QB or one that is well below Boyle (i.e. scout team QB) in backup situations – even in junk time. The writing on the wall is fairly clear at point, don’t you think? I haven’t talked to Boyle and don’t know him personally, but I don’t think they have disenfranchised Boyle up to this point. He is simply just not better than Whitmer. I don’t exactly understand the one series per game bit, but has he really shown that he deserves more playing time?
Anyways, this is the last time I’m addressing Boyle’s (lack of) redshirt. You have your opinion and I have mine. I understand you POV (as well as the POV vis a vie McAllister), but it’s pretty clear at this point that we are not going to convince one another to cross over. So…There it is.