My sense is that she didn't even KNOW she had a concussion (which she might not actually have) until she tried to practice on Sat. Then they put her through the protocol and she's doing well, according to Geno. No reason to think she's "not normal" at this point. She's checked every box to recovery. I fully realize that severe concussions can be life-altering. This hardly seems like that. Why are you stretching to make this seem so dire?Over a week since the concussion, and she's still not normal. I'll bet her parents are very distraught. Forget the game. Let's hope that she makes a full recovery soon. Sports are replete with stories of young kids who suffer bad concussions and never play again.
Hoping for her good health.
(which she might not actually have
If participating in a full contact practice without symptoms is the last step before playing, and if UConn is only having a non-contact practice between now and tomorrow night then why is she listed as questionable? I would think that no practice would mean OUT for the DePaul game.
She went from unproven freshman on the bench, to a much needed and depended upon 6th man spark off the bench.
If she is suffering concussion symptoms, she suffered a concussion. If someone is having after-affects of a concussion for over a week, it's serious. Certainly we hope that it all clears up, and nothing like this ever happens again. But let's be clear that this is brain damage. And it's cumulative. And each succeeding trauma to the brain tends to make it easier for a concussion to occur. So were I this young lady's parent, I would be concerned.
Of course, we're all hoping that this was the first concussion, and that she hasn't suffered more in the past. But the fact that it appears that she suffered this concussion with such a glancing and modest blow to the head makes one wonder if it wasn't her first.
Fingers crossed.
That's not true Carnac. You know she's our new PG. Geno is just getting her mind right.
I don't think anyone said she's "not normal" - they're just following the protocol, and they started it way late because of the Thanksgiving holiday. In the NFL it takes about 3-4 days (or 3-4 minutes if the player is really needed). This is a very long time for a normal concussion protocol.Over a week since the concussion, and she's still not normal. I'll bet her parents are very distraught. Forget the game. Let's hope that she makes a full recovery soon. Sports are replete with stories of young kids who suffer bad concussions and never play again.
Hoping for her good health.
No, Rocky, but what, precisely IS a concussion and how is it determined? does any of us here know? Maybe if there's a previous EEG to establish a baseline and then one to compare it to after the collision, I would imagine (I do not know) that one could make a scientific call. But barring that, it's descriptive of symptoms, not analytical. And there will be concussions which are obvious (e.g. can't answer easy questions) and ones that aren't (e.g. where the patient has to self-report a headache). What we've done, appropriately, is in all instances err on the side of caution. All manifestations of symptoms are therefore called concussion-like and treated with the same protocol as if it were a concussion. And to the extent one quickly progresses through the protocol, we declare the patient safe to compete again.Just something a tad short of that bags? They don't have her in the protocol for laughs. If we lose one or two in December and have Crystal flummox opponents for the rest of the year I'm good with that. Don't need no Jamie Carey drama here! Gag, did that kid milk that drama or what! Never seen Geno look more scornfully at an opponent. Can't find the pix.
For a great education on sports-related concussions, read League of Denial by Mark Fainaru-Wada (investigative reporter who wrote Game of Shadows and broke the Barry Bonds/BALCO scandal) and Steve Fainaru (Mark's brother).No, Rocky, but what, precisely IS a concussion and how is it determined? does any of us here know? Maybe if there's a previous EEG to establish a baseline and then one to compare it to after the collision, I would imagine (I do not know) that one could make a scientific call. But barring that, it's descriptive of symptoms, not analytical. And there will be concussions which are obvious (e.g. can't answer easy questions) and ones that aren't (e.g. where the patient has to self-report a headache). What we've done, appropriately, is in all instances err on the side of caution. All manifestations of symptoms are therefore called concussion-like and treated with the same protocol as if it were a concussion. And to the extent one quickly progresses through the protocol, we declare the patient safe to compete again.
Certainly, symptoms can persist for months--even years--afterwards. A dear friend and great doctor is now unemployable because of her concussion. So no minimizing on my part. My plea is not to speculate, not to impute emotions to her parents, etc.
I've dealt with more player concussions (at high school level) than I care to count. With our protocol it almost always takes at least two weeks to get back. If Crystal was practicing non-contact yesterday that would seem to indicate no serious difficulties.Over a week since the concussion, and she's still not normal. I'll bet her parents are very distraught. Forget the game. Let's hope that she makes a full recovery soon. Sports are replete with stories of young kids who suffer bad concussions and never play again.
Hoping for her good health.