Coaching Rumor Mill Churns - John Silver

[huskymedic]

I don't get the tie-in between the chat and the article - are you saying that everything Silver writes now needs to be viewed w/ skepticism?

I'm saying I have a jaundiced view of Silver from his whole body of work on P/GDL, from this chat -- the snide comment about GDL's longevity is telling -- to his stories/blogs which took a similar tone that they were good coaches but Edsall didn't leave any talent for them.

Ok - So... it has nothing to do with what he said in this specific article? I was just trying to figure out how this ended up in this thread? Thought I missed something.

 

[ruskin]

To sum up

Decent stuff by Silver, but never forget he he was a Pasqualista / DeLeoneaista.

Then thought it would be helpful to give an example of what I was talking about. Then we got "loopy", so to speak.