Fair. But I went to Vandy. And I feel I can blame the staff for that one. That's the only one that I fault him for.
Sure, but none of the victories had anything to do with him, though....right? I mean, that is what you are saying. You're saying that his 5 wins would have all been achieved by Edsall (or someone else), and only his losses were in the balance, right? Does another coach beat a favored USF with this roster? Does another coach beat a very competitive Syracuse team with this roster? Does another coach absolutely whallop a favored Rutgers team with this roster??
The answer is, "I don't know." I'm not trying to give him a free-pass for anything. I'm trying to call it as fairly as I can. But I can't just say that the losses are on him, and not give any credit for the wins. And I don't think anyone else should either.
Syracuse went 1-6 last year in the Big East. What exactly is your definition of competitive?
I remember when coach P, was givin the job, this board bash Uconn Hathaway for doing this, well I think we should give prop 2 both since Coach P, been here look at Uconn recruits or transfers, QB , 2 WR, lineman, 2 LB, and these kids r big time players, under Coach Edsall this wasnt happing, so 2 Coach P, continue 2 play it by your rule, go Uconn
Syracuse went 1-6 last year in the Big East. What exactly is your definition of competitive?

P should shave his head bald and go with the Bruce Willis look . He would look 10 years younger and this nonsense of him being too old would go away. I'm saying this as someone who has successfully shaved away the gray. It works.
Coach P has ON PAPER, significantly improved our recruiting prowess in a very short 15 months.
P should shave his head bald and go with the Bruce Willis look . He would look 10 years younger and this nonsense of him being too old would go away. I'm saying this as someone who has successfully shaved away the gray. It works.
, and i hope P grows his hair long a la Rob Ryan.I thought the Pitt game was an unmitigated disaster and the team looked like it quit, which can happen in college football. It is such a game of emotions that young players have trouble turning it around when a game goes against them.
Other than that, I thought Pasqualoni was pretty good during the season.
Agreed. Things have been encouraging since the close of the '11 season. Now . . . fans need to see improvement on the field. Last season was awful. Need to win more than 5 games. Need a "benchmark/signature" win (an NC State win will offer a lot more "currency" than a win over Buffalo). Oh and while I'm at it . . . some exciting football, particularly on offense and perhaps through the air. : )
I wasn't sure where else to put this but check this out. Is Randy Edsall kidding me?
Dwayne Gratz @DJG24_7
Can't believe I just seen Randy Edsall in Storrs with nothing but Uconn gear on, **** was too funny
Expand
last season wasn't awful. i agree we do need to win more than 5 games, if you think last season was awful you really need to get a passport out of fantasy land. we had an awful lot of issues going into the season with a new coach, new scheme, new QB and RB, among other issues, but all that being said we were in bowl contention until our last game. sometimes college football teams have bad years. it the nature of the short term career of a college athlete. how do you think Texas fans felt when they went 5-7 in 2010? it happens
With the pieces they had to work with?Score some points for gosh sakes.
That was on Coach P? I think it reinforces the point above about the pieces they had to work with.And, the posterboy play for '11 was the sack, strip, TD to open the Cincy game. Come on, throw it away or take the safety, but to get your lunch money taken away?
Only if you have the right head shape for it... I would look like Butterbean and King Kong Bundy had a child... not attractive.P should shave his head bald and go with the Bruce Willis look . He would look 10 years younger and this nonsense of him being too old would go away. I'm saying this as someone who has successfully shaved away the gray. It works.
last season wasn't awful. i agree we do need to win more than 5 games, if you think last season was awful you really need to get a passport out of fantasy land. we had an awful lot of issues going into the season with a new coach, new scheme, new QB and RB, among other issues, but all that being said we were in bowl contention until our last game. sometimes college football teams have bad years. it the nature of the short term career of a college athlete. how do you think Texas fans felt when they went 5-7 in 2010? it happens
just want to remind everyone the hideous way the Vandy, Iowa State and Western Michigan games were lost. All three had various levels of coaching blunders. Please don't make those losses Edsall's fault, there was enough talent on the field to win. Good thing is I don't think Manuel/Herbst are giving P the long leash others seem to want to give him.
Can you please explain to me how the Iowa St. loss was on the coaches? That's the one game that I think people have no right to rip the coaches for. There were plays to be made all over the field that night. All night long.
That loss is on the players. It happens sometimes.