Mutually exclusive.
No one said they couldn't win games in the tournament. Going .500 in the ACC proves they can beat tournament teams. But their resumes, Cuse's in particular, did not warrant inclusion.
Well...I don't know about how you compare resumes between a reasonably good team from the ACC-Big 10-Big 12 and a good mid major. Sure, there is RPI, wins in groups, SOS, etc...but still not any real method that is totally objective.
That has always been a problem...Trying to compare group members from disparate groups.
It is also why we went, in the 80's, to norming in promotional exams and college entrance tests.
Blacks and Hispanics were compared to only those in their group...so a 90% ranking in one group may be a lesser ranking in the total conglomerate group.
The tops of each group were reported as being equal.
The courts have weighed back and forth on "banding".
But weighing two resumes from disparate groups is still somewhat fraught with difficulty.