Consensus First Team players:
Donyell Marshall, 1994
Ray Allen, 1996
Richard Hamilton, 1999
Emeka Okafor, 2004
Kemba Walker, 2011
Consensus Second Team players:
Richard Hamilton, 1998
Rudy Gay, 2006*
Hasheem Thabeet, 2009*
Honored by a major publication:
Chris Smith, 1992 (Honorable Mention - AP)
Ray Allen, 1995 (3rd Team - AP, NABC, UPI)
Doron Sheffer, 1996 (3rd Team - UPI)
Khalid El-Amin, 1998, 1999, 2000 (Honorable Mention - AP)
Caron Butler, 2002 (2nd Team - Sporting News; Honorable Mention - AP)
Emeka Okafor, 2003 (3rd Team - NABC; Honorable Mention - AP)
Ben Gordon, 2004 (Honorable Mention - AP)
Josh Boone, 2005 (Honorable Mention - AP)
Marcus Williams, 2006 (Honorable Mention - AP)
AJ Price, 2008 (2nd Team - USBWA; Honorable Mention - AP), 2009 (Honorable Mention - AP)
Jeff Adrien, 2009 (Honorable Mention - AP)
Jeremy Lamb, 2012 (Honorable Mention - AP)
*There were publications that had both of them as first team AA that year.
**The website I was looking at (wikipedia) did not have Honorable Mention slots listed for 1993, 1994, or 1995. It's entirely likely that Marshall was Honorable Mention in 1993, and that someone like Donny Marshall or Doron Sheffer were Honorable mention in 1994/1995.