They were funny but only a few of the guys were super funny. Don Rickles was really, really good. There’s a lot of latitude given on reviews of those old roasts because it’s kind of surreal to be watching Dean Martin and Frank Sinatra up there. They are legendary figures and there’s an element of nostalgia that’s undeniable.
I found the Brady roast very funny. It was absolutely crude, but that’s part of the act. Nikki Glasser prides herself on making you uncomfortable, that’s just part of the method she uses. There’s other comics, like Nate Bargatze, that are totally clean. That doesn’t make him better, it’s just a style. I don’t think he’d be nearly as funny if he did a crude act. Different personalities and styles. I guarantee you, they find each other funny but they understand the craft.