Reply to thread

Message: [QUOTE="superjohn, post: 4033484, member: 1522"] Last time I was at Sally's I ordered it because of everything I've read here and from the urging of people in line. It tasted like you would expect tomato sauce on bread would taste. I mean it's edible but I have no clue why people would order it over a regular cheese pie or any of their other pie. The second pie was good if underwhelming compared to all my other Sally's visits over the years but the first tomato pie ruined the experience so much for my eating partner that we left New Haven annoyed we just didn't go to Modern. Went back in for Modern later on the trip and it was good as always. [/QUOTE]