An Experiment Failed...

[ASweet3781]

I just read the thread the OP was referring to and barely saw any negative comments directed towards the OP?

 

[JS]

I just read the thread the OP was referring to and barely saw any negative comments directed towards the OP?

There's a certain kind of poster whose message can be paraphrased as "I'm brave to be saying this, and know I'll be pilloried for it, BUT . . . [insert negative assessment of player or team, justified, partially justified, or unjustified]."

Then at the first sign of disagreement: "No one dares take an independent view here. It's all [insert choice of: party line, good ol' boy, blue-colored glasses, rah-rah, Geno can do no wrong, intolerant of dissent and/or aggressive toward anyone who fails to toe the line]."

A little homework might reveal to such a person that we actually have civilly conducted disagreements here, and that just maybe we mods prevent injuries more serious than a boo-boo.

You have to wonder whether someone who wears a self-inscribed "kick me" sign like that is really interested in dialogue so much as in playing the courageous martyr.

 

[tomcat]

I don't have an issue with what they say - I may disagree with some of it, but am ok with them posting it. I just get the feeling that there is some trolling going on here. Of course I may just be paranoid.

In fairness, I have to say that if this is the worst trolling we can see, we are either dealing with amateur trolls or maybe, just maybe, they are what they say they are and not trolls.

 

[tomcat]

#1florida, I reply and quote you because the OP ran out of the house as fast as he/she came in.
No attack as you insinuate you would receive here just my opinion on the situation the OP put him or herself in and the one you seem to pursue.
Let's begin....Welcome to The Boneyard, that could almost be like saying welcome to The Hotel California, but not going to get that deep here.

Nobody attacked the OP or even used slander type insults of any kind. There were differences of opinions, possibly strongly verbalized but nothing more. It should be noted anyone posting on this forum for the first time should do some homework. The first time OP came in admonishing the recruiting, use of the bench and the future of the program. He/she is walking into a room of team supporters for a few decades and saying our leader is doing it wrong. The recruiting is weak and the bench is not being properly used. This about a program that not only the head coach is in the hall of fame but the assistant also???? This while they are in the midst of a so far still undefeated season while taking on a out of conference schedule of nothing but the best.

Again nobody attacked or said anything out of what is just a difference of opinion. This was probably a different forum for the OP as much as I think it may be for yourself. I say this as you are in fear of being attacked here along with your slander of calling this forum a good ole boys club.
I welcome you and suggest as the OP should have done is do some homework. Nobody gets attacked here period...I can tell you I enjoy several sports forums and this is the Good Ship Lollipop. If someone is attacking anyone they are quickly removed. My own avatar of Diana Taurasi ESPN cover for over a year was removed without explanation.
In closing on this one please realize a large portion of the people on this forum are women. No way that this is a what you call a good ole boys club! Join in lighten up and realize there are a lot of good times/ laughs to be had here. Some may be at your expense but we all have been there to.

Can't disagree with a word of this here. As I said in an earlier post, one criticism of the OP was a bit rough for my taste, but there was no one wringing him/her out and hanging him/her out to dry. Just didn't happen. I hope the person sticks around, but if they are too thin-skinned for even this, maybe it's for the best if they don't.

 

[Crossover]

Please don’t feel that you’ve caused a problem for the OP. He could have Reported the post he objected to , asked you to tone it down or otherwise have called you on your perceived insult. Instead, he chose to assume things about the Boneyard at large and posted a very aggressive screed. What is seen here is edited, as were follow up comments by the OP. You aren’t responsible for any of that.

Thanks for this. I had a feeling the OP weighed in a second time, in a manner that was inflammatory. We non-mods should bear in mind that a lot of clean-up occurs outside our purview.

 

[Buckaroobanzai]

Uh...I apologize for causing such a stir with what I thought were rational "opinions:" on my part. I had no expectation one way or another as to what the reactions would be. Nothing I said had anything to do with the so-called "facts" that seem to be written in stone here, and never to be questioned or commented upon. They were my opinions based my current observations of the team, regardless of their current or past record. Now I have been accused by a number of individuals of expecting everyone to agree with me. Apparently the requirement is for new members to lay low and not disagree with anyone or have a personal opinion not in keeping with pre-established facts. Sorry, this is not the place for me. Have fun.

I reviewed the original thread to which SpockLogical posted and found healthy and vigorous disagreement but nothing that challenged SpockLogical’s competency to posit his or her opinions. In the present thread, SpockLogical rather overemphasizes relatively innocent contrary observations and apparently concludes that he/she has effectively been driven from the board. Frankly, I think that SpockLogical doth protest too much.

 

[Stinger92860]

I took a shot a joining the Boneyard with the idea in mind that there would be room for another individuals opinions and ideas. Yesterday I posted some replies in the thread:
Louisville beating UConn aint in the CARDS

A number of responses to my thoughts on the Uconn women and Geno had a tone of arrogance and self-righteousness suggesting that my comments were illogical, un-sound, and that I was incapable of knowing the definitions of words in the English language. Nothing in anything I wrote in my commentaries was demagoguery or condescending. My thoughts on the program were just an opinion. I am a avid supporter of Geno and his team. I was born and raised in Connecticut. I do not profess to being an expert on basketball, but at 70 years of age, maybe I have been able to pick up some knowledge, along the way, that others on this board have not.

There is a systemic level of intolerance in our society today and a lack of respect for the opinions of others. You see it everywhere. I thought that might not be the case here. I was wrong. That is sad.

Welcome to the internet