Reply to thread

Message: [QUOTE="intlzncster, post: 3063797, member: 56"] This is a difficult question as they play two different positions with varying need. Right now we desperately need somebody to back up Carlton, and Precious is not that. Need might outweigh overall impact just from a team building perspective. But irrespective of need, for me personally? I'd rather have Precious. But that's for specific reasons; I can see how others might choose differently. His athleticism/aggression would absolutely dominate the American. I think he'd be a superior defender of 2 to maybe 3 positions right from day one (certainly better than Steve). And I'm still not sold on Steve's consistency game in game out. We'd get a less polished offensive player, to be sure, but one who's aggression/athleticism might make up for some of that deficit. Also, there's the 5 star 'cache' factor, though I know that's not what we are talking about. [/QUOTE]