Part of what I'm not sure how works is, so you pay up to get freshman and he does well, do you still have to out bid other schools for his sophomore season? Then why pay up freshman year if doesn't give you advantage keeping him for next year, think it was advantage for Ball and Stewart (Ross also but he wasn't as hot a commodity), even for 3rd year. Coaches need to judge players and themselves, freshman who left after last year were in bad place vs. playing time so combination of good guys staying/coming in and them not seeing playing time/development for this year (and maybe coaches seeing same thing).
Will be interesting to see how Stewart and Ross fair this year (assuming don't go pro) and how they handle portal or not next year (even Ball if he doesn't go pro). Also, any of the freshman would don't go pro and show out some this year. Really is interesting dynamics.