Personally, I'm not ready to put Aaliyah and Morgan Tuck in the same sentence yet. Aaliyah has not shown the amazing deliberate footwork of Morgan, hitting outside shots, or running offense from the high post. Let's not get ahead of ourselves. I'd like to see an elbow shot next game. Baby steps.
I would bet on Anna to win that battle. Evina’s best 3 point % at Tennessee was 38% as a sophomore. Even without having spent the last two years without playing a game, she is also still trying to get fully healthy, while Anna showed last year that she is (I think it is fair to say) at minimum a 40+% on 3 pointers. Evina is clearly a better defender, I would say passing is basically even with perhaps a lean to Anna, E provides more leadership and is (I believe) a calming/nurturing influence for the freshmen. If E were fully healthy, I would (somewhat reluctantly) choose her over Anna. However, I know from personal experience just how difficult it is to be forced to stop doing something that you did at a high level for several years and then to attempt to get back to that level. Shooting imho is more difficult to get back than dribbling, passing, and defending, and since outside shooting seems to be somewhat lacking on this team, I would have to say that E will likely move to the first option off the bench if/when Aaliyah becomes a starter. Of course, it is possible that Geno will value defense and leadership over 3-7 percentage points on threes.If Edwards cracks the starting lineup it will be to replace either Evina or Anna. Which one depends on who shoots better from the perimeter, as it is currently a team weakness. Beyond that, both are producing near identical numbers in similar minutes.
Any doubt about Aaliyah? Her mentality is really astonishing
Great post. Geno is no dummy. AE will get her minutes!!!
From an offensive point of view, Anna wins that battle most probably, although at some point, I think EW can do things that Anna can't do like break down a defense with penetration. However, on the defensive end, AM may be a liability in some or even many games guarding the wing player on the other team. I can see AM given minutes at the 4 and 3, depending on matchups.I would bet on Anna to win that battle. Evina’s best 3 point % at Tennessee was 38% as a sophomore. Even without having spent the last two years without playing a game, she is also still trying to get fully healthy, while Anna showed last year that she is (I think it is fair to say) at minimum a 40+% on 3 pointers. Evina is clearly a better defender, I would say passing is basically even with perhaps a lean to Anna, E provides more leadership and is (I believe) a calming/nurturing influence for the freshmen. If E were fully healthy, I would (somewhat reluctantly) choose her over Anna. However, I know from personal experience just how difficult it is to be forced to stop doing something that you did at a high level for several years and then to attempt to get back to that level. Shooting imho is more difficult to get back than dribbling, passing, and defending, and since outside shooting seems to be somewhat lacking on this team, I would have to say that E will likely move to the first option off the bench if/when Aaliyah becomes a starter. Of course, it is possible that Geno will value defense and leadership over 3-7 percentage points on threes.
I hear ya there. But we are all excited (as is Geno!) from what we saw. To be honest, if she only gives us a 'strong inside presence' and can get some offensive rebounds and put them back in, provide some D and give some minutes, that is all we need from her. That alone could equate to 10 and 10 every night. The girl is strong, athletic and brings it.I love what I have seen so far... but let's slow down the AE roll just a little. She provides a strong inside presence (I think I've see a few BY posts about needing more bigs... lol). But, we have played two undersized teams, and she has not showed she can make anything other than a layup. I hear she can hit the 15 footer, but I have not seen that yet. I think her ceiling is very high, given her strength and athleticism... but's let's wait just a bit before we anoint her the next Tina Charles.... or Aisha Jones....
I agree that the team is going to need more of Aaliyah to go deep. I think the quote from @JoePgh , "To advance in March, you need a strong inside presence -- offensive rebounding, defensive rebounding -- and she provides that." is quite telling. I know this is the minority opinion (and I am ready for the fall out) Buuut, I am not on the Olivia bandwagon. I know it's early but we have played two relatively small clubs. Games that were there for Liv to dominate and she played well. But she should have dominated and did not. My opinion is she is too nice and plays too polite. I expected monster improvement this year and really have seen none. She has the same habits that caused her difficulties against better posts last year. Namely she starts her shot very low, frequently around the shoulder. I'm no talking about her 15 footer, but underneath the hoop. Secondly she has to gather herself to make a second jump. Now I admit that she looked terrific catching the ball on the run and scoring open layups and also I was shocked that she made 3 15-17 footers. (I think that was an abberation based on her catapult shooting style and her free throw percentage). Compare Aaliyah's stat line for the last game against Liv's when Liv played 25 minutes and Aaliyah played 18. Remember which player sent the opponents flying and which was knocked off her shot by shorter players, thus preventing and 1's. In the future I don't see us benching Anna because we need her threat of 3's and she also makes the offense flow. I think Aaliyah's minutes come from Liv. Now I understand that many feel that we need Liv's defensive presence and I also remember many BY posts about her swatting at shots.
Stewie ruined it for every post player that ever decides to attend UConn........We keep saying Olivia needs to do this, Olivia needs to stop doing that, Olivia needs to bulk up, Olivia needs to develop this post move. Olivia is a junior now. OK she HAS improved on the swatting down and fouling, and she could still develop her post offense (although there’s no evidence of this). At this point I suspect we’re pretty much seeing what we’re going to get from Olivia. She isn’t going to totally transform into a different player.
We do need Olivia for what she does provide - especially Olivia the rim protector. But I think starting Aaliyah along side her at the 4 makes us a lot better matchup vs. elite teams with size. I’d like to see that experiment begin right now, work the kinks out and have it humming by the time we face Baylor & SC.

Agree with the energy Jamelle brings. Let's not forget that CD coached bigs for many years and many championships. She likely deserves credit as well. Nice to have both.I think we are witnessing the benfits of having Jamelle in practice and on the sidelines. She has the same fire as she did in the NCAA final four, and it translates well into Edwards's game.
I agree completely with your assessment as well for these first two games. I pray that it will continue and cressendo in the Baylor and South Carolina matchups, and be maintained in all the games in between....