UConnNick
from Vince Lombardi's home town
- Joined
- Sep 17, 2011
- Messages
- 5,073
- Reaction Score
- 14,066
UConnNick-nice job with the counterpoints of the issue with one/two minor rebuttals if I may-
The conference alignments are about the 2, and only 2 revenue sports: Football/MCBB. In order to compete in CFB 35-50% of your recruits need to be regional i.e.New England, otherwise you can't field depth. Add in 11 paid assistants and large fan base to donate and come to the games and you see the issue. No New England University or for that matter Eastern Seaboard team north of Virginia can compete in CFB. So why waste the money, tax dollars and cost of other programs to try?
Forego football, focus on Basketball, baseball, hockey, lacrosse, soccer, swimming and other sports where the Northeast pool of talent is abundant. The Big East does offer significant competition in all of those sports. The BigEast WCBB is still better than the AAC-besides DePaul, there's Marquette, Villanova and Creighton all in the top 50 on Massey and Georgetown/St.John's all in the top 72. AAC has 2 in top 50 and 3 in top 72 with UCF. As you say, you should look at the other sports as well and think of the more regional travel to take the burden of the other sports to compete-Butler, Creighton and Xavier being the furthest with only Creighton not in the Eastern time zone.
I do know the issue is not dead and I think with UConn Hockey showing life, the budget situation will start to determine where funding needs to go as the Connecticut Tax payers do not want to subsidized D1 football... JMHO..
You're right about the state budget crisis. UCONN won't be in a position to maintain AD funding at current levels forever. I don't agree, however, that a nationally competitive CFB program cannot be built in the NE US. We did it in the mid to late 2000's, Rutgers did it back then and has started to get competitive in the B10, and from time to time Syracuse and BC have had their moments.
At some point though, the money is going to run out. There are a lot of sunk costs involved with the infrastructure for football. Walking away from that will require an admission of defeat as to improving our conference situation, not to mention the state gets stuck with a 90 million dollar white elephant in E. Hartford.
I don't think switching from one mid major conference to another moves the needle in any appreciably positive way. It's a reshuffling of the same deck. The NBE provides some travel benefits, but we still won't have the top level competition we need to attract the best recruits across all sports. It might help with men's BB a little, but long term we end up in either a newly created second tier of the NCAA, or the P5's form their own governing body and leave everybody else behind. We'll be competing for secondary level NCAA titles.