Funny. Last season when UConn destroyed teams with their small lineup, Ash was on the court with Azzi, KK, Sarah and Paige. So the only difference this season is Serah for Paige. Hard to see how Ash could thrive in one lineup and not in another?
Oldude, I think you might be straddling two different discussions.
The one discussion is whether the team is ultimately better served with Ashlynn coming off the bench rather than starting. Last year following the loss to Southern Cal right before Christmas, Geno's went with a
starting line-up was almost exclusively Sarah, Jana, Kaitlyn, Azzi and Paige (the only two exceptions were when Paige sat out a game and for Senior Night). I think folks would agree that was not a "small ball" starting line-up.
The small ball rotation, that you correctly pointed out Ash was an effective part of, never started any game. Like Ash and KK, it collectively entered the game as a disruption force (my term). It was wonderfully effective, and aesthetically pleasing to boot.
The second discussion is about what is the small ball rotation/line-up this year and does it involve Ashlynn. The current starting line-up (for just two games) has been Sarah, Serah, Ash, Azzi and KK. Very effective so far, but certainly not a "small ball" line-up.
Against Florida State, Geno didn't go with a "small-ball" rotation until midway through the second quarter. Assuming BballF's Chronological Rotations post (separate thread that was also tweaked by Gael) is all-inclusive, for the remainder of the game Geno used five different small ball rotations, only one which involved Ashlynn -
for a total of about eight seconds. The remainder of Ash's 20 minutes was with at least two bigs on the court with her.
This was different than the first game against Louisville where, according to BballF, Geno employed three different small-ball rotations among the 19 rotations he used, each of the three involving Ashlynn.
So the take away from the BballF's rotation analysis: in the first game small-ball involved Ashlynn and was very effective, the second game small-ball did not involve Ashlynn and was also very effective.
My position: Ashlynn is effective whether she starts or comes in off the bench. She is also effective whether she is used in small-ball, or in rotations with multiple bigs on the floor. She is a Swiss army knife, and will be integral to the team's success going forward.
Two interesting discussions. What a great position the program is in for us to be having them.