Location of the stenosis on the spine matters, but typically
spinal stenosis is not something to screw around with in any way, shape, or form. Ty-Meer Brown and his family may have pursued and obtained additional medical checks providing some assurance the initial reasonable diagnosis was appropriately cautious, and they still chose to take chances others might avoid. Alternatively, later checks might not have viewed the issue quite as seriously. Or perhaps, BCU's just willing to take more chances with a kid's future health and well being than UCONN.
Quoting Brown from the Courant article:
" 'They (UCONN) just didn’t want to let me go any further with the condition I have,' Brown said. 'It was tough but things happen, situations occur, you’ve just got to move forward from it but I didn’t want to believe it obviously because I had been so close to my dream and for them to tell me I can’t play anymore it was just devastating. I don’t really feel anything. It’s a condition I was born with and they just figured it out after all of these years of me playing football.' "
Other comments were similarly interesting:
Desumond Conner: "I had been hearing Brown was having a really tough time accepting it all and that hasn’t changed. It’s understandable for a competitor like Brown.
His father, Tim, a former middle linebacker and captain on West Virginia’s 11-0 1993 team, had an injury that would sideline him and UConn athletic director Warde Manuel, a standout defensive end at Michigan, who sustained a career-ending injury in college, have talked to Ty-Meer quite a bit to help him cope."
Brown: “[Manuel] kept encouraging me, just making sure I keep my head up and things like that because he didn’t want to see me go in the tank, He said I’m a good person on and off the field. He wanted to make sure I was maintaining the right mindset to move on. My dad went through it, too, yeah. He was sidelined. He’s just been really supportive and that’s all I can really ask for.”
None of us know all of the facts or are likely to learn enough of them to truly judge the decision. However, you like to think Brown's health is OK short term and have to hope it's reasonable playing more football won't expose him to very serious long term issues of an avoidable nature.