nelsonmuntz
Point Center
- Joined
- Aug 27, 2011
- Messages
- 44,220
- Reaction Score
- 33,097
I hope that report of over 9.5 minutes of CPR before getting into the ambulance is not accurate. 9.5 minutes is a long time.
Was it because of a game injury or did he collapse for no known reason?
Not exactly sure yet. He made a routine tackle that involved helmet contact, got up momentarily like he was okay, then just collapsed backwards. Scary as heck to watch. Game is currently suspended.
I read this earlier too. Praying Damar Hamlin is on the 58% sideA doctor on CNN says he suffered Commotio cordis. Commotio cordis is a phenomenon in which a sudden blunt impact to the chest causes sudden death in the absence of cardiac damage.
Can you survive commotio cordis?
Without immediate CPR and defibrillation the prognosis of commotio cordis is not very good. This condition is extremely dangerous with rare survival.
Hamlin was defibrillated on the field.
From wikipedia:
Commotio cordis (Latin, "agitation of the heart") is an often lethal disruption of heart rhythm that occurs as a result of a blow to the area directly over the heart (the precordial region) at a critical time during the cycle of a heart beat, producing what is termed an R-on-T phenomenon that leads to the condition. It is a form of ventricular fibrillation (V-Fib), not mechanical damage to the heart muscle or surrounding organs, and not the result of heart disease. The survival rate is 58%, which is an increase in comparison to years 1993–2012, where only 34% victims survived. This increase is likely caused by the prompt CPR, access to defibrillation and higher public awareness of this condition.
Not sure of Cincinnati protocols, but most prehospital protocols call for 20 minutes of high quality CPR in the field.I hope that report of over 9.5 minutes of CPR before getting into the ambulance is not accurate. 9.5 minutes is a long time.
How does this send a message? What new information has been generated that is actionable for HS coaches?Hope this sends a message to high school and college coaches too that player health and safety are paramount.
While that is true, in the case of a 24 year old healthy individual like Hamlin, as opposed to a 70+ year old with an extensive medical history, 20 minutes of CPR in the field goes out the window. Get the kid to the nearest stabilizing facility as fast as possibleNot sure of Cincinnati protocols, but most prehospital protocols call for 20 minutes of high quality CPR in the field.
Gotta believe he got CPR and defibrillation as quick as humanly possible. I guess it depends on how quick they got the heart beating again.A doctor on CNN says he suffered Commotio cordis. Commotio cordis is a phenomenon in which a sudden blunt impact to the chest causes sudden death in the absence of cardiac damage.
Can you survive commotio cordis?
Without immediate CPR and defibrillation the prognosis of commotio cordis is not very good. This condition is extremely dangerous with rare survival.
Hamlin was defibrillated on the field.
From wikipedia:
Commotio cordis (Latin, "agitation of the heart") is an often lethal disruption of heart rhythm that occurs as a result of a blow to the area directly over the heart (the precordial region) at a critical time during the cycle of a heart beat, producing what is termed an R-on-T phenomenon that leads to the condition. It is a form of ventricular fibrillation (V-Fib), not mechanical damage to the heart muscle or surrounding organs, and not the result of heart disease. The survival rate is 58%, which is an increase in comparison to years 1993–2012, where only 34% victims survived. This increase is likely caused by the prompt CPR, access to defibrillation and higher public awareness of this condition.
They have to make player safety a higher priority if they don't want kids, teens and young men heading to the hospital.How does this send a message? What new information has been generated that is actionable for HS coaches?
I thought we already were making player safety a higher priority? Fact is, FB is a blood sport now. Not playing the game is the only way to protect kids.They have to make player safety a higher priority if they don't want kids, teens and young men heading to the hospital.
(Paramedic firefighter with 36 yeas of EMS experience)While that is true, in the case of a 24 year old healthy individual like Hamlin, as opposed to a 70+ year old with an extensive medical history, 20 minutes of CPR in the field goes out the window. Get the kid to the nearest stabilizing facility as fast as possible
here are some initial steps:I thought we already were making player safety a higher priority? Fact is, FB is a blood sport now. Not playing the game is the only way to protect kids.
This is a freak, unfortunate incident on a fairly mundane tackle.They have to make player safety a higher priority if they don't want kids, teens and young men heading to the hospital.
Here is just one example.
Minnesota high school football player paralyzed after 'normal' play
The Bloomington teenager was left motionless on the field after a hitwww.cbssports.com
Oh wow, you’ve got a few years on me. When a veteran shares his knowledge I’ve always found it best to stop and listen. I should have specified, once ACLS had been established, I personally, would have felt comfortable continuing CPR while in transport, especially due to his age and that it was a witnessed arrest. But yes you are absolutely correct, CPR in an ambulance is difficult. I’m glad I wasn’t the medic on that call(Paramedic firefighter with 36 yeas of EMS experience)
Nothing necessarily "goes out the window" if somebody is in ventricular fibrillation. The need to restore a heart rhythm takes priority. The immediate care for this condition is the same in the field as it is in the Emergency Department. CPR is difficult when underway in a moving vehicle, and high-quality CPR, ventilation (not sure if he was intubated on the field or not) and defibrillation is paramount. Once his heart rhythm was restored, he was transported.
In the event that his arrhythmia could not be converted, rapid transport for more invasive treatments would be a higher priority.
Back in the 80's we would almost always rush to the ambulance with patients in cardiac arrest....often down multiple flights of stairs. No effective CPR could be done while trying to make this move. We will take our time and provide the best quality compressions while establishing IV access for medications that may help stabilize a normal heart rhythm along with defibrillation. Once the outcome either changes positively or remains negative, transport (or, more recently, presumption of death in cases not involving someone this young and healthy) becomes the priority.
Sucks to be the medic in such a high-visibility event. I've seen tons of uninformed comments on social media attacking the on-field care and EMS for "taking so long."
(Paramedic firefighter with 36 yeas of EMS experience)
Nothing necessarily "goes out the window" if somebody is in ventricular fibrillation. The need to restore a heart rhythm takes priority. The immediate care for this condition is the same in the field as it is in the Emergency Department. CPR is difficult when underway in a moving vehicle, and high-quality CPR, ventilation (not sure if he was intubated on the field or not) and defibrillation is paramount. Once his heart rhythm was restored, he was transported.
In the event that his arrhythmia could not be converted, rapid transport for more invasive treatments would be a higher priority.
Back in the 80's we would almost always rush to the ambulance with patients in cardiac arrest....often down multiple flights of stairs. No effective CPR could be done while trying to make this move. We will take our time and provide the best quality compressions while establishing IV access for medications that may help stabilize a normal heart rhythm along with defibrillation. Once the outcome either changes positively or remains negative, transport (or, more recently, presumption of death in cases not involving someone this young and healthy) becomes the priority.
Sucks to be the medic in such a high-visibility event. I've seen tons of uninformed comments on social media attacking the on-field care and EMS for "taking so long."