WVU's Play by Play Guy on Rumors | The Boneyard

WVU's Play by Play Guy on Rumors

Status
Not open for further replies.

CL82

NCAA Men’s Basketball National Champions - Again!
Joined
Aug 24, 2011
Messages
56,840
Reaction Score
208,185
Link took me to WVU Defensive coordinator discussion. Nothing at 7 minute mark.
 
Joined
Aug 27, 2011
Messages
7,501
Reaction Score
15,690
So then it must not be him and it must be safe to listen.
No it's actually the WVU play-by-play guy. It's really good....gives a perspective from the B-12 play-by-play announcers. Also gives a interesting different view on the bad side of BYU.
 

MattMang23

Adding Nothing to the Conversation
Joined
Sep 21, 2011
Messages
5,150
Reaction Score
14,742
No it's actually the WVU play-by-play guy. It's really good....gives a perspective from the B-12 play-by-play announcers. Also gives a interesting different view on the bad side of BYU.

Yeah it was a good listen. Nice and encouraging.
 
Joined
May 29, 2015
Messages
1,741
Reaction Score
7,580
I don't know, I don't buy the fact that BYU is not likely to get in cause they are a "Pain in the butt."

That's annoying, but if they bring in the money there is no way Big 12 leadership won't suck it in and invite them. Money talks.

So if BYU is not getting in, there has to be something more there than just them being awful to work with. Perhaps their footprint is being exaggerated or something else, but I don't buy for a second that the Big 12 will say no because they are obnoxious.
 
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
3,768
Reaction Score
5,422
Got more info from those guys then all of the CT media combined. But we all know the reputation of WV guys.....
 
Joined
Apr 25, 2014
Messages
5,292
Reaction Score
19,788
I don't know, I don't buy the fact that BYU is not likely to get in cause they are a "Pain in the butt."

That's annoying, but if they bring in the money there is no way Big 12 leadership won't suck it in and invite them. Money talks.

So if BYU is not getting in, there has to be something more there than just them being awful to work with. Perhaps their footprint is being exaggerated or something else, but I don't buy for a second that the Big 12 will say no because they are obnoxious.

I can absolutely see the heavy hitters in the B12 being unwilling to make concessions to a team they're adding, and BYU would require some concessions. Rescheduling of tournaments, etc.
 
Joined
Nov 2, 2011
Messages
771
Reaction Score
3,396
I don't know, I don't buy the fact that BYU is not likely to get in cause they are a "Pain in the butt."

That's annoying, but if they bring in the money there is no way Big 12 leadership won't suck it in and invite them. Money talks.

So if BYU is not getting in, there has to be something more there than just them being awful to work with. Perhaps their footprint is being exaggerated or something else, but I don't buy for a second that the Big 12 will say no because they are obnoxious.

The problem (as I see it) with BYU is that while they do bring interest due to the LDS members, what MARKET do they bring?

For a conference network, you have to bring a market so you can charge in-market rates for the network.

BYU may have national appeal, but if you can't monetize that fanbase, it's worthless.

Also, are advertisers going to line up to advertise to the BYU fanbase? To me, that's another issue. I'm pretty sure the church frowns upon liquor and tobacco use.
 
Joined
Feb 22, 2016
Messages
84
Reaction Score
438
I don't know, I don't buy the fact that BYU is not likely to get in cause they are a "Pain in the butt."

That's annoying, but if they bring in the money there is no way Big 12 leadership won't suck it in and invite them. Money talks.

So if BYU is not getting in, there has to be something more there than just them being awful to work with. Perhaps their footprint is being exaggerated or something else, but I don't buy for a second that the Big 12 will say no because they are obnoxious.

BYU would have received an invitation to the Big 12 before TCU did, but obviously BYU wanted the conference to make concessions, concessions that would have put some of the other members at a disadvantage. ESPN found BYU and its lawyers very difficult to work with and in the end, it recommended the conference not consider BYU for membership. It is not likely the conference will revisit talks with BYU, especially after the decision was made to invite WVU as the 10th member.

Big 12's television partners said no to BYU - The Salt Lake Tribune

BYU learned the hard way that it isn't the Notre Dame of the West (like some of the its fans like to consider themselves).
 
Last edited:
Joined
May 29, 2015
Messages
1,741
Reaction Score
7,580
BYU would have received an invitation to the Big 12 before TCU did, but obviously BYU wanted the conference to make concessions, concessions that would have put some of the other members at a disadvantage. ESPN found BYU and its lawyers very difficult to work with and in the end, it recommended the conference not consider BYU for membership. It is not likely the conference will revisit talks with BYU, especially after the decision was made to invite WVU as the 10th member.

Big 12's television partners said no to BYU - The Salt Lake Tribune

BYU learned the hard way that it isn't the Notre Dame of the West (like some of the its fans like to consider themselves).

Ok now THIS makes sense. It's not just that they are a pain in the butt, but that there hardheadedness was going to cost the conference money.
 
Joined
Feb 22, 2016
Messages
84
Reaction Score
438
Ok now THIS makes sense. It's not just that they are a pain in the butt, but that there hardheadedness was going to cost the conference money.

No one is talking "causing the conference money" here. The Big 12, as a 10-school league (with TCU and WVU), was still getting paid as if it still had 12 schools in the conference. ESPN/FOX did not have to renegotiate the Big 12's media contract for a lesser amount just because BYU was not invited. And hey, when ESPN is paying the bills, you listen.

BYU wanted to play by its own set of rules and the conference was not going to allow that to happen.
 
Joined
May 29, 2015
Messages
1,741
Reaction Score
7,580
No one is talking "causing the conference money" here. The Big 12, as a 10-school league (with TCU and WVU), was still getting paid as if it still had 12 schools in the conference. ESPN/FOX did not have to renegotiate the Big 12's media contract for a lesser amount.

BYU wanted to play by its own set of rules and the conference was not going to allow that to happen.

If ESPN says no and the Big 12 tells them to pound sand and invites BYU anyway, you don't think that's going to hurt them moving forward?

You don't piss off your TV partners. Just ask John Marinatto.
 
Joined
Feb 22, 2016
Messages
84
Reaction Score
438
If ESPN says no and the Big 12 tells them to pound sand and invites BYU anyway, you don't think that's going to hurt them moving forward?

You don't piss off your TV partners. Just ask John Marinatto.

How is what you are saying, different from what I said in my posts?
 
Joined
May 29, 2015
Messages
1,741
Reaction Score
7,580
How is what you are saying, different from what I said in my posts?

I suppose its not, but then why were you refuting my claim that BYU admission wasn't costing the conference money?
 
Joined
Feb 22, 2016
Messages
84
Reaction Score
438
I suppose its not, but then why were you refuting my claim that BYU admission wasn't costing the conference money?

The Big 12 (as a 10 school league before Texas A&M and Missouri departed) already had a negotiated contract with ESPN and Fox. Thanks to the former Big 12 commissioner, ESPN and Fox were agreeable to paying the conference the same as if it still had 12 schools.

When Texas A&M left, the conference was obligated to find a suitable replacement quickly that would keep the Big 12 from breaching that contract. BYU would have been a suitable replacement in the minds of the top brass at ESPN and Fox, but that fell through after BYU made its unreasonable requests. The media partners then approved TCU as a suitable replacement for A&M.

This scenario repeated itself when Missouri left and West Virginia was invited. WVU had to sue its way out of the Big East (with $10 million financial backing from the Big 12) in order to join the Big 12 for the 2012 season. Had that not happened, the conference would have been in serious trouble with the media partners.

So to go back to your argument, there is no way BYU was costing the conference money just because it wasn't invited. That still holds true to this day.

It's funny that BYU's coach Mendenhall had to go public with begging the Big 12 for membership.

BYU’s Mendenhall welcomes a Big 12 invite, if only it would be extended – CollegeFootballTalk
 
Last edited:

HuskyHawk

The triumphant return of the Blues Brothers.
Joined
Sep 12, 2011
Messages
31,968
Reaction Score
82,078
The Big 12 (as a 10 school league before Texas A&M and Missouri departed) already had a negotiated contract with ESPN and Fox. Thanks to the former Big 12 commissioner, ESPN and Fox were agreeable to paying the conference the same as if it still had 12 schools.

When Texas A&M left, the conference was obligated to find a suitable replacement quickly that would keep the Big 12 from breaching that contract. BYU would have been a suitable replacement in the minds of the top brass at ESPN and Fox, but that fell through after BYU made its unreasonable requests. The media partners then approved TCU as a suitable replacement for A&M.

This scenario repeated itself when Missouri left and West Virginia was invited. WVU had to sue its way out of the Big East (with $10 million financial backing from the Big 12) in order to join the Big 12 for the 2012 season. Had that not happened, the conference would have been in breach its contract.

So to go back to your argument, there is no way BYU was costing the conference money just because it wasn't invited. That still holds true to this day.

He is saying that in the long run, inviting BYU would cost the conference money, as they would irritate the networks.
 
Joined
May 29, 2015
Messages
1,741
Reaction Score
7,580
The Big 12 (as a 10 school league before Texas A&M and Missouri departed) already had a negotiated contract with ESPN and Fox. Thanks to the former Big 12 commissioner, ESPN and Fox were agreeable to paying the conference the same as if it still had 12 schools.

When Texas A&M left, the conference was obligated to find a suitable replacement quickly that would not breach that contract. BYU would have been a suitable replacement in the minds of the top brass at ESPN and Fox, but that fell through after BYU made its unreasonable requests. The media partners then approved TCU as a suitable replacement for A&M.

This scenario repeated itself when Missouri left and West Virginia was invited. WVU had to sue its way out of the Big East (with $10 million financial backing from the Big 12) in order to join the Big 12 for the 2012 season. Had that not happened, the conference would have been in breach its contract.

So to go back to your argument, there is no way BYU was costing the conference money just because it wasn't invited. That still holds true to this day.

I think the confusion is that my argument isn't that not inviting BYU cost them money, but that inviting them would eventually cost them money.

Yes, under the existing contract they had they BYU entering as team 10 as opposed or in addition to TCU (as 11) they wouldn't of cost the conference any money, but their stubbornness and ESPN/FOX's general dissatisfaction with the school could cost the conference money in the future.

That's all I am getting at.
 
Joined
Aug 27, 2011
Messages
7,501
Reaction Score
15,690
The Big 12 (as a 10 school league before Texas A&M and Missouri departed) already had a negotiated contract with ESPN and Fox. Thanks to the former Big 12 commissioner, ESPN and Fox were agreeable to paying the conference the same as if it still had 12 schools.

When Texas A&M left, the conference was obligated to find a suitable replacement quickly that would keep the Big 12 from breaching that contract. BYU would have been a suitable replacement in the minds of the top brass at ESPN and Fox, but that fell through after BYU made its unreasonable requests. The media partners then approved TCU as a suitable replacement for A&M.

This scenario repeated itself when Missouri left and West Virginia was invited. WVU had to sue its way out of the Big East (with $10 million financial backing from the Big 12) in order to join the Big 12 for the 2012 season. Had that not happened, the conference would have been in serious trouble with the media partners.

So to go back to your argument, there is no way BYU was costing the conference money just because it wasn't invited. That still holds true to this day.

It's funny that BYU's coach Mendenhall had to go public with begging the Big 12 for membership.

BYU’s Mendenhall welcomes a Big 12 invite, if only it would be extended – CollegeFootballTalk
Then Mendenhall up and left BYU for UVA. That to me was more telling than anything that BYU isn't going to make concessions for any conference.
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Online statistics

Members online
653
Guests online
3,316
Total visitors
3,969

Forum statistics

Threads
156,859
Messages
4,067,490
Members
9,948
Latest member
ahserve34


Top Bottom