Shaq was better than Drummond in college ATM
Oden was better than Drummond in college ATM
Dwight as a rookie was better than Drummond ATM
Athleticism is an interesting thing. Shaq could get up when he was young. Oden wasn't as athletic as either, but he had a great post game (shame what happened to him). Shaq was also fairly quick getting down the court when he was young, faster than Dwight IMO as well.
Keep in mind this is subjective and based on memories from 10+ years ago of Shaq.
Overall, Shaq was heads above both Howard and Drummond IMO when he was in college and Howard was probably more advanced defensively than Drummond at the same age. Drummond has three things over both of them. I think his handle is better (though for a center that's not a huge concern), his smoothness and he is a deer out there. The question is, can he get as strong as Shaq and Howard and maintain his speed? It also will be interesting to see how much he can learn defensively. He still has issues with backscreens and such. His positioning for rebounding isn't 100% either, though it was better for most of the WVU game.
His smoothness is the most amazing part of his game. He has all the physical ability to be one of the best centers ever. He also is missing a lot of the basketball IQ and fundamentals to actually become one of the best centers ever.
As amazing as Drummond is, he is so raw. I equate it to JPP on the NFL Giants, he can be physically dominant out of college without necessarily knowing a ton about the fundamentals of the game. Drummond can get better at almost all facets of the game:
- Positioning in general (he is improving on this)
- Boxing out (he is improving on this)
- FT shooting (he is improving on this, couldn't get worse)
- Back to the basket moves (dunking on someone really isn't a move)
- Face up game (hard to tell in college, this is really not part of the game in college)
- Defensive awareness (backscreened a few times last game by guards)
That short jumper of his is actually pretty consistent and fairly quick, he might have to adjust it for the NBA, but there are not a lot of people that will challenge it in college. His recovery on defense is really impressive as is his help defense. He has great hands both in snagging rebounds and getting passes as well as when reaching for steals (not something I like to see him do, but he is quite good at it). His passing (Rutgers being an exception) is quite good as well.
I can see how people would say Drummond coasts, he really makes it look easy, yet is down the court faster than most guards and doesn't seem to give up on plays.
In the end it's going to come down to how hard he works and how good of a coach he has in the NBA. If JC can turn Okafor into a double double NBA guy, I think Drummond is in good hands.