Why offensive line is the toughest position for college football recruiters to evaluate (Feldman/The Athletic) | The Boneyard

Why offensive line is the toughest position for college football recruiters to evaluate (Feldman/The Athletic)

Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
87,350
Reaction Score
325,452
Great long-ish read... and if you don't have access, have Santa/Wife/Kids get you a subscription for Christmas - It's less than a buck a week for a year.

Feldman: Why offensive line is the toughest position for...

>>This week when your favorite team announces its signing class, or when you hear about the four- or five-star recruit that your school did or did not get, remember this number: 2.4.

That is the average star ranking of the 15 offensive linemen voted to the Pro Bowl last year who were evaluated in the era of the recruiting star system. None of them were ranked as five-star prospects; four were four-star guys — the same number as there were zero-star players. Joe Thomas, the best offensive tackle of his era, went to 10 Pro Bowls in his 11 seasons. Thomas once was ranked as the nation’s No. 18 offensive tackle prospect. None of those 17 graded ahead of him went on to start in the NFL as tackles. From the 2015 signing class, prospects who are seniors now, Clemson’s Mitch Hyatt is the only four- or five-star O-line recruit (according to 247Sports) to make first-team all-conference.<<

>>Getting a sense of just how much they actually love football is another must. “I’d take a three-star guy that loves football over a five-star guy that loves recruiting any day,” Hand says.<<

>>Getting to know the kind of person who you are recruiting — what makes them tick, how tough they are, or just how important football is to them — is harder now than ever because the recruiting calendar has sped up so much.

“You can kinda get to know them over social media,” Kelly says. “Nowadays, a lot of kids don’t like talking over the phone. That’s the hard part. How well can you get to know him based on the rules now? Camps are an important part. You have to see how they work. You get them in camp and you want to see what can this kid pick up when we start doing drill work? What type of learner is he?”

McLeod, who runs Duke’s recruiting operation, says everybody recruits the same 40 offensive linemen. “And then you get past them, it’s like who are we gonna get? That’s why camp is so important. But now everybody’s throwing out those meaningless offers and kids don’t even want to come to camp.”<<
 
Joined
Aug 26, 2011
Messages
20,532
Reaction Score
44,582
Made me laugh:

. “The way the recruiting services (that college programs utilize) work now is that once a school offers a kid, other recruiting offices get emails notifying them,” one Power 5 recruiting coordinator says. “It’s like a bat signal.”
 
Joined
Aug 5, 2017
Messages
3,313
Reaction Score
8,096
How many stars were Anthony Sherman? Was he even a 1 star?

He was a 2 star in his class, along with Twyon Martin, Kendall Reyes, Robbie Frey, Jasper Howard, Greg Lloyd Jr.,
Dave Teggart and Mo Petrus. That was RE1.0 and here's hoping we get the same results with 2.0.
 
Joined
Aug 28, 2011
Messages
27,048
Reaction Score
66,087
Edsall has always found very good offensive linemen. It's his gift. For some reason he can look at a 17 year old and figure out what he'll be like at 20.

Offensive linemen are tough to evaluate because there is no "type" that guarantees success. If you go for athletic undersized high school linemen and try to build them up, they may lose their quickness and athletic ability as they get bigger. If you go for high school kids that are already big and developed, they may not play anywhere as well when they match up with larger college age defensive linemen.

The above makes it extremely difficult to project how they will develop as college players. It is one area where Edsall excels.
 

Online statistics

Members online
614
Guests online
3,022
Total visitors
3,636

Forum statistics

Threads
156,800
Messages
4,064,760
Members
9,943
Latest member
jjblox


Top Bottom