Reply to thread

Message: [QUOTE="RSHERMVIKES, post: 2302276, member: 2251"] When I think of MLB's Hall of Fame candidates I always think of was that player dominant in his era? All the candidates at that level have similar stats but were they really dominating MLB when they played? If they did dominate, then they were Hall of Fame worthy! I think Mike Messina, Jim Kaat, Morris - with Twins/Tigers/Blue Jays, Ron Guidry, Dave Stewart, Thurman Munson among others fit my criteria! How is Edgar Martinez a Dan Hurley, not qualified for the Hall of Fame? For the UCONN Wall of Honor, Jamelle Elliott, Kia Nurse (possibly), Tiffany Hayes, etc. were talented enough to get AA honors to earn their way on the Wall, but played on stacked teams where all the qualified didn't get a vote! That didn't make them any less talented! But I agree you've got to draw the line somewhere! [/QUOTE]